Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethics. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Overpriced Education Is a Moral Issue

Inside Higher Ed has a respectable write-up of the small shrinkage in law school enrollments coming this fall to at least three campuses. This quote, from California law professor John Yoo (originally posted here back in March), struck me as rather naive:
The decision to reduce the size of a law school class has little to do with morality (though it may have a lot to do with moralizing) and everything to do with economics. Education is a product in the market, like any other. The producers (law schools) sell a service (a legal education) at a price (tuition) to consumers (students). If there is an oversupply of the product, or the demand falls, then the price should drop and eventually the quantity will fall until the market clears. I don't see anything so moral (or immoral) about it.
While his economic analysis is technically correct, education is absolutely not "like any other [product]." I probably should be baffled that a professor at a "top" university is grossly oversimplifying a situation to cleanse his own guilt, but I'm not.

When someone buys almost any other product or service, any liability created by the purchase can be removed by filing a bankruptcy petition. Providing normal credit is an example that would fit into his model. Because consumers can declare bankruptcy and erase the transaction from being a burden, there's nothing "moral" or "immoral" about a credit card company that raises or lowers rates, or creates new cards/marketing pitches to give the illusion of scarcity, etc. The bank retains some risk in the transaction, so economic principles can entirely guide their actions.

Conversely, some jackasses in Congress decided that student loan debt should be treated differently than all other debts. The schools - like Yoo's University of California - sell a product, often with gross exaggerations fueled by fantastical myth-making - with absolutely no risk on the credit side of things, either to the school or the bank.

Because student loan debt is non-dischargable with a standard bankruptcy petition, the risk of a education being a bad investment falls entirely on the students and their parents when they need to use credit (which 90+% do).

At that point, a school's decision to enroll students takes on a moral element. Unlike normal producers, who either have an incentive to sell to those who can pay or can only provide services to credit-worthy people, the schools' abilities to draw in any consumer and saddle them with debt-for-life gives the school a position of power divorced from economic reality. The fact that Yoo even suggests that the market can or will "clear" is perplexing; the market has been willfully prevented from "clearing" for decades by the ABA and the law schools, including his employer.

Plus, educational institutions often invite moral disapprobation by marketing themselves as leaders, subtly vilifying corporate America, justifying their high costs as "good" debt, holding themselves up as prestigious institutions and community-based institutions, etc., which gives them more culpability that Joe the Auto Mechanic, who's at least honest when he says he just wants to make a living.

My gut reaction to Yoo's comment is that he's too enmeshed in the system - and therefore a party to stockpiling some students with unsustainable debt loads - to see a moral issue and moral culpability where it's obvious. After all, if you admit that ruining innocent parties financially is a moral issue, a whole lot of people need to trudge their way to confession tomorrow. Can't have that, now, can we?

Almost every immoral event and practice can be explained in basic economic terms. Slavery's rise and fall, for example. Or teenage prostitution in Thailand. That doesn't make them non-moral issues. A professor of law should know better.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Update on Rakofsky Story

This is from three days ago, but I think most commenters missed it and I didn't see it until late last night, but the Washington Post did a follow-up on the Joseph Rakofsky story (the recent Touro grad who decided to defend one charged with homicide in a different state). The Post found the defendant's grandmother, and her explanation of how he wound up to be her grandson's attorney is - well - completely unsurprising:
Watson, 71, said she told Rakofsky that she wasn’t interested in hiring him even for the murder case because the family couldn’t afford the $25,000 to $30,000 normally charged in such cases.

But Rakofsky, 33, called her, Watson said. And again. She said he told her that he had worked on criminal cases before. And he told her that he would charge $10,000. Watson decided to “give him a chance,” she said, impressed with his tenacity and his willingness to work on her grandson’s case, especially for such a low fee.
Note there's multiple dynamics at work here. Race-to-the-bottom fees? Check. High-pressure sales tactics? Check. Exaggerated representations to clients to get them to hire a desperate soul? Check.

And remember all that verbiage deans spit out about how more lawyers equals lower fees for poor people? Isn't that exactly what happened here? Isn't this the ABA's wet-dream: a family priced out of the homicide defense market can now buy the product because Touro - God bless them - keeps spitting out attorneys so desperate for work they'll do it for 50-75% off. Poor people can finally afford representation - hallelujah!

But, like settling for a cut-rate prostitute, it had its consequences. Of course, the fact that I just compared cut-rate attorneys to $25 prostitutes should signal that something's wrong, even if it's mildly funny-'cause-its-true.
Web sites and bar licenses don’t provide enough information, said Saul Singer, senior legal ethics counsel for the D.C. Bar. Potential clients need to get references and check out a lawyer’s reputation, Singer said.
Yeah, that sort-of kills the whole idea of this being a well-regulated "profession," doesn't it?

And to complete the hucksterism:
During a two-hour phone conversation, Watson said, Rakofsky declined to refund her money.
I don't know if I can say this enough, but a 15k attorney surplus each year leads to more Lionel Hutzes on the market, so this should not be seen as a one-time story. Because many students are swamped with debt and pigeonholed as lawyers, they will not easily exit the market. Many 2009 and 2010 graduates of varying quality are still looking for jobs. The desperation level will rise along with the ethical tensions as young lawyers try to price themselves competitively.

For better or worse, this is the system our elites have created. The true tragedy here is that their response is not to fix the system, but to circle the wagons and place the blame entirely on the Rakofsky's of the world. As I've said before Rakofsky is an idiot worthy of blame. But he's got a big-time accomplice in a system that fails at multiple points.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Joseph Rakofsky: Both an Idiot and a Symptom

This entry was corrected for possible minor errors due to possible discrepancies I learned of during the week of May 16. A summary of the minor changes can be seen here.

Others have already commented on the Joseph Rakofsky story, but in reading commentary on the issue, I'm a bit bothered by how many people want to call him a moron and move on as if that's the end of the inquiry.

To refresh everyone's memory, Rakofsky, a 2009 Touro grad with very little actual experience, and a law license in New Jersey, decided to try a murder case in Washington, D.C. As one might expect, it did not go well, and multiple people, including the judge and the Washington Post courthouse reporter, found Rakofsky's performance a sign of "incompetence." I trust their judgment.

Is Joseph Rakofsky an idiot? Absolutely. Let us count the ways.

But he's also a symptom of one of the fundamental problems of attorney oversupply. Back in December, I pointed out that having a large mass of desperate unemployed attorneys can put ethical obligations into jeopardy in the context of foreclosure mills. There, attorneys looking for a job - any job - would have an incentive to sacrifice morals to bring in a paycheck.

Rakofsky is the Horatio Alger, "pull himself up by his bootstraps," side of that same coin.

Rokofsky's website is now down, but here is his "About Me" paragraph that I rescued from google cache:
Mr. Rakofsky has worked on cases involving Murder, Embezzlement, Tax Evasion, Civil RICO, Securities Fraud, Bank Fraud, Insurance Fraud, Wire Fraud, Conspiracy, Money Laundering, Drug Trafficking, Grand Larceny, Identity Theft, Counterfeit Credit Card Enterprise and Aggravated Harassment. Following graduation from law school, he worked for one of the biggest civil litigation firms on the east coast and has worked for boutique white-collar criminal defense firms in Manhattan. During law school, Mr. Rakofsky interned at the Legal Aid Society (in Suffolk County). Prior to studying law, Mr. Rakofsky studied Economics and interviewed at a well-respected investment bank with branches all over the world. Prior to law school, Mr. Rakofsky earned a Bachelor of Science in Biology, concentrating his attention on DNA.
Hey, my attention was concentrated on DNA too, specifically the kind at Tri-Delt. But I digress again.

It's clear that Rakofsky's bio is milking every minor experience he's ever had especially since he just graduated in 2009. Filed a service return for a credit card collection? Sounds like identity theft experience to me! But this is the monster we've created. The options for attorneys who can't find real jobs out of law schools are either to try something else, settle for doc review-type jobs, or set out on their own. Commentators often promote the idea of setting up shop as a viable alternative to getting a job, and many law school deans (Thomas Mengler, as one example) justify purposefully flooding the market by claiming that more solos and firms means lower prices and better lawyering (a really stupid conclusion, but that's for another day).

Well, here we have a kid who clearly wanted to do criminal law. He set up a slick website (financialcrimelaw.com; great url!) to make him look like the smooth legal hucksters on TV. He set up four offices. To account for his relative virginity, he listed every conceivable experience he could. Such is necessary to compete with the 40+ crowd who market their prematurely-gray hair like a badge of honor rather than a sign of stress.

Isn't this exactly what the Menglers of the world want him to do? Even if it isn't, is this not the natural result when you saddle kids with $100k+ in debt and pigeonhole them into an overcrowded field? Aren't they going to set up sleek websites and offer discounts and hope and pray that they make it through their first cases without looking like a doofus? After all ,can't have a gap on the resume. Must be working, getting out there, networking with other solos, gaining experience. Prior to last week, most industry apologists would have likely held up Rakofsky as an example of what unemployed law graduates should be doing, that they should be entrepreneurial.

But entrepreneurship is not good when the product being peddled is an inferior quality and public welfare is placed at risk. Rakofsky may not have even been aware that he was peddling an inferior product; he probably honestly believed he was competent, and such is part of the problem with a "Wild West" view of licensing, accrediting, and more or less forcing some graduates to solo it.

Everybody lost except the people at Touro who cashed his tuition checks. Everybody.

In medicine, graduates of medical school are not allowed to just "hang a shingle" and set up their own practices. They must go through a 3-5 year period called residency where they learn to actually practice medicine on real people in real hospitals. You are not allowed to become board certified and practice medicine without supervision until you have completed a residency program. All graduates of medical school programs are more or less guaranteed a space in a residency program because the medical profession actually cares about integrity and welfare and limits the output of medical schools. They made a sound policy decision to be cautious and prevent unprepared doctors from being unleashed on the public.

I hold no illusion that law is as important as medicine, but I completely fail to see how anyone in their right mind can continue to license attorneys to do things that they are entirely unqualified to do. Why is there not a residency requirement, or the equivalent? Changing law school to be two years of study and two-three years of low-paid study under a practicing attorney doesn't seem to be too big of a burden. Neither does requiring specialization or making the bar exam more practical to the actual day-to-day practice of law in a specific jurisdiction.

The system is completely broken. It cannot filter out people like Rakofsky; instead it allows them to flow through by the thousands and onto an unsuspecting marketplace. It has no training safeguards to ensure that people handling murder cases can actually handle murder cases. The more hubris-filled unemployed attorneys will do exactly what Rakofsky did; his story made the rounds, others' do not. But he is by no means unique. He is exactly what happens when you license type A personalities to do things before they've actually shown they can do it.

We do not license people to drive classes of vehicles they have never touched before. We do not license surgeons who have never held a scalpel. Yet in many cases attorneys can handle matters they know little about merely because they've duped some poor client into believing they're "the guy."

A real profession doesn't let that situation develop, and it stops the nonsense once it becomes apparent.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

AALS Desperate as Bubble Bursts, Seeks to Halt New Accreditation Standards

If there's one thing that's true when gravy trains end and organizations start shedding people, it's that the everyone suddenly will go to great lengths to explain how important they are.

Hence, a grossly overstated letter by the AALS to Hulett "Bucky" Askew regarding some proposed changes to the ABA's accreditation standards. Props to Paul Caron at TaxProfBlog for hosting it and pointing it out. I'm not going to reprint it all here, but I definitely encourage my readers to check it out for some light chuckles and some sterling examples of "begging the question" or "assuming the conclusion" logical fallacies.

For example, the letter characterizes the SRC's proposal as a "thought experiment" that may undermine the present legal education system. But one must ask: where is the proof justifying the structure of the current legal education system? Is it merely enough that we've done a thing a particular way for decades? I think not.

But that doesn't stop AALS from trying to justify its members' jobs.

Wow, where do I start? Probably by stating the obvious: this is bullshit. There is absolutely no empirical proof that the "scholarship and public service" allegedly carried out by full-time faculty "give [their teaching] an authority" that adjunct teachers cannot. None, nor is the valid reason to assume this. After all, if I have a choice between one professor who actually represents real people in the local federal court and another who hasn't seen a courtroom in 20 years, who is going to have more "authority" behind his teaching? Hint: it ain't the guy who writes journal articles on esoteric theory.

Honest to goodness, law is a professional school designed to teach professional skills. What student ever values someone more because they write an unread article or do public service? And why are adjuncts somehow foreclosed from such things? Many practitioners write more relevant articles than full-tenure professors, anyway, and there's no reason to believe a law professor is any more committed to public service than a non-professor.

"[O]nly full-time career faculty can be expected..." reeks of baseless elitism. To buy into this rhetoric, one would have to assume that there's something truly different about full-time faculty. The entire letter seems to assume this without any empirical proof and relying on dubious conclusions (e.g., that American legal education is "high quality") and outright misstatements (e.g., law is not a "fundamentally public profession").

The point of an American legal education is to train competent lawyers. There is no evidence, nor is there any logical reason to believe, that that goal necessarily requires a full-time tenured faculty. And they do demand their tenure, see p. 5: "[Full-time faculty] remind students of the clients who encounter law and the students' ethical obligations as lawyers, and they facilliate the process of learning about law, lawyers, and the meaning of justice." Again, this can't be done by part-time non-tenured faculty?

There are a variety of other sub-issues (like distance learning and the LSAT), but the gist is that the professors feel threatened by the contemplated changes:

Ah, yes, bureaucratic stalling. Of course, if there were any real discussion of "first principles," the law professors would lose, and badly. Law school is not a scientific academy or a liberal arts college; it is a professional school designed to train people who can actually walk into court and argue and file items on behalf of a client. There is no evidence whatsoever that such a process requires a robust full-time faculty of academics indistinguishable from their liberal arts peers aside from paycheck and the type of elitist condescension on display.

The real factor that "make[s] reform desirable" is that law professors don't actually teach students how to be lawyers. That's a "first principle." To hell with social justice and the "valuable" aspects of legal education if the law schools can't even do that.

Cost, of course, is another factor making broad reforms desirable. This system clearly is not sustainable, and professors that make $200k a year make a very sane target for cuts. But the AALS has a defense for this: it isn't the professors making double their value that increase costs, it's the students and the rascally people in the admissions department:

Translation: before cutting full-time staff, cut career services or scholarships!

Because basically what we have here is a ten-page letter full of fear and bold statements that is absolutely devoid of any substantive proof of what it's claiming. Full-time professors are supposedly just "better" than other options, more ethical, more service-oriented, and more apt to gain expertise (than, you know, the actual people filing claims in court). Most generic students, I suspect, wouldn't be able to tell a full-time tenured faculty member from a part-time adjunct.

All this is is raw, naked self-preservation wrapped in a coat of hollow rhetoric and baseless assumptions about how great legal education has been in the last few decades. I don't necessarily support all the standards changes, but I think they're a move in the right direction and the AALS' attempt to derail them in "let's do a study" hell is shameless and militates against any finding that organizations like the AALS exist for any "public service."

They're clearly not, or else this letter would look radically different.

Monday, March 28, 2011

On Legal Technology and Conservatism

I'm back from my brief vacation, and today I'd like to first point out an informative, yet somewhat repetitive, article from Texas Lawyer about trends in the legal industry. What really caught my eye is this tidbit on lawyer technology:
E-Discovery Costs: The annual litigation survey published by Fulbright & Jaworski reports that nearly 40 percent of the respondents expressed the need to increase spending on electronic discovery. This concerns them, given the already high cost. As one possible solution, a few firms are partnering with e-discovery vendors because they believe it is cost-effective for both the client and the firm.
Keep that in mind. Next, I'd like to point out this tidbit from a recent article on legal research, entitled "Legal research moves from the print library to expensive digital databases:"
This same generation is now leading the legal industry's leap to the Web -- a revolution with major implications for clients, bringing more firepower to those who can afford it and more headaches to those who can't.

"Today, virtually 100 percent of practitioners use online research," said David Dilenschneider, who oversees content development for LexisNexis. "You really cannot practice in books these days. It isn't doable because of the risk of missing information."

LexisNexis and Westlaw provide massive databases of statutes and judicial opinions, plus proprietary goodies like analyses and explanations.

It's that proprietary content, along with advanced search algorithms and other fancy tools, that make the two services the most effective in the industry -- and the most expensive.

First, the "proprietary content" is available for free in brick-and-mortar libraries if you already know directly where to look, and you can find it in about 30 seconds. The advantage of the online services is mostly speed and volume, being able to search thousands of cases and documents at once for key phrases. The most valuable "proprietary" services are probably the ones that tell you if something has been overruled or not, and maybe the notifications on new cases in a particular area, but neither of these is impossible to the layman without the services.

Second, it's a really odd time to complain about the expense of Lexis and Westlaw. Why? Well, because both are facing significant competition from free sources and have had to take measures to keep traffic up. Westlaw has introduced WestlawNext, which is dramatically cheaper and provides more services, not necessarily because old Westlaw was bad, but rather because they feared losing customers to free sources. Lexis decided to start a free service, called LexisOne, that's basically a large archive of caselaw.

Contrary to the implication of both of these articles, technology is a cost-saver over the long term. The cost "raises" in both legal research and in discovery is because the technology was fundamentally abused, or used not as a tool of efficiency.

In legal research, both Westlaw and Lexis used the technology more or less as an excuse to jack prices. While sets of books under the old system of expansive law libraries were not cheap, it was a one-time expense to purchase the book and there was something of a secondary market that could exist for the volumes (from law offices closing or law libraries updating their collections) and for those resourceful enough to go to a law library, there was very little access cost. The existence of the internet changed that by letting Westlaw and Lexis charge for mere access to the materials and not just ownership.

Of course with the internet and what are, ultimately, readily-available materials for the resourceful, that set-up can't last, and it didn't, and that's why both services are desperate to retain customers now in a dwindling marketplace.

The same basic idea applies to discovery abuses. I know less about complex litigation than legal research, but it seems to me that the advent of the internet did not make discovery more expensive aside from broadening what discovery could include. The most obvious example of this, to me, is e-mail. Previously, 99% of what is sent over e-mail would have been phone conversations without record or would have never been sent or would have been used and discarded. Now there's terabytes of data storage of useless shit that plaintiffs want to get at for that microscopically small fraction that may be useful. That's not technology making a process more expensive, it's the people using it changing their behavior.

In theory, computerized technology should lower costs and it should be fairly straightforward if basic ethical principles are plainly laid out, but it hasn't immediately been readily adopted or accurately priced in the legal profession, and there seem to be no shortage of seminars or symposiums or verbal sewage about the implications of technology, as if the legal profession is run by antediluvian buffoons.

Because largely, it seems, it is. From the first article I cited:

Social Media: Issues are arising. Clients are increasingly asking for counsel on employees' use, and the management, of social media. Firms are now recognizing the need to develop electronic and social media policies for themselves.There are ethics considerations. There are challenges for lawyers in maintaining the confidentiality of client information. And there are many issues with respect to the use of social media in litigation. One report may have summed it all up: "The law has significantly lagged behind social networking."
Really, there aren't "many issues" unless you start making them up. How hard is it to tell people not to post something on facebook about a client? Or to develop a social media policy? It's really no different than telling employees not to gossip about clients at the coffeehouse, is it? Basic ethical principles applied to a new setting; this is not new.

And who is "the law?" It isn't students, ground-level working attorneys, or the like. It's the regulators, the wizened old men who like to spout platitudes with no substance, and, ultimately, the bar associations run by "seasoned veterans." Together, they implant a very conservative, retrogressive way of doing business, where new technologies are hostile because they all bring major ethical crises (real or fictional) and concocted expenses.

If the legal profession were really concerned with justice, it would welcome new technologies and the cost-savings associated with them. Furthermore, you virtually never hear any of the legal talking heads suggest that technology make actually improve ethics considerations even though, in some cases, it becomes easier to comply with ethical mandates as technology advances.

But the legal profession really isn't concerned with access to justice or cost savings or ethics; it, like every other profession, is concerned with keeping the kings of the hill at its profitable apex. Any tectonic shift may shake them from their place, and it's better to keep litigation costs artificially high. Because those in the business have an incentive to keep the status quo, the market was slow to respond to the need for cheaper research tools and cheaper e-discovery mechanisms.

This system also snakes its way into law school corridors. Properly using technology could result in major cost savings in legal education. For example, textbooks are now archaic fossils no longer necessary; all the materials needed for a legal education can be found by plugging into the internet and bringing a moderately-priced laptop to class. And yet, the thick >$100 volumes persist, a tremendous waste of resources, time, and energy. Worse, some people have the audacity to suggest that technological advances are making a legal education more expensive. That's out-and-out bullshit and a lousy justification for the rampant tuition increases of the last 15 years.

While it's not the biggest of the profession's problems, the fact that crusty Luddites seem to disproportionately work as lawyers compared to other professions seems to cause more problems than it solves.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Is Reverse Auctioning Coming to Legal Profession?

It appears so-called "reverse auctions" are entering the legal field, where prospective clients can present their case and attorneys can bid to do the service for them.

This is from the ABA Journal:
[Robert Grant] Niznik’s graduation musings led him to contemplate the plight of indebted law students struggling to find a job in a bleak economic climate as well as the expensive and largely inaccessible nature of the legal profession. His answer to both issues is at once goofy and serious. The New York Law School student founded Shpoonkle, a playfully named website that allows attorneys and law firms to bid on legal requests submitted by clients. The service is free for now, but Niznik said attorneys may be charged membership fees in the future.
"Shpoonkle" is a horrible, horrible name, and I think there are numerous potential pitfalls that have to be overcome (e.g., the clients' incentives to lie seems higher than if they're in a one-on-one initial consultation, and if the lawyer's aren't allowed to ask questions before bidding, I could see the site becoming a platform for misrepresentation). However, the fact that people are developing such technologies should surprise no one, and I think this is a positive sign that the real dangers of lawyer oversupply may become present.

By way of example, I'd like to discuss the sports card market's collapse in the early 90s. For example, in 1990-1993, a Ryne Sandberg 1993 Topps rookie card was "worth" approximately $35-40 in mint condition according to price guides that monitored the market. By the late '90s, the price had dropped dramatically (to $15 or so) and today - even after Sandberg has been inducted into the Hall of Fame - one can buy a Sandberg rookie card for about $4.00 on eBay. Sandberg's career trajectory cannot explain that by itself, as the same phenomenon can be witnessed in the value of other cards from the 70s, 80s, and 90s (e.g., this card once went for $100+). Factoring in inflation, that's a major collapse.

Why did it happen? The initial knee-jerk reaction might be that the strike of 1994 and the steroid era forever ruined baseball's popularity. But the same effect can be seen in other sports as well (see this, for example). Rather, what happened in the mid-90s was that the development of the internet (specifically eBay) destroyed the supply/demand illusion that previously dictated prices. See, prior to eBay, sports card values were set by price guides (like Beckett), who purported to monitor sales. People involved in private one-on-one transactions had no idea what the true supply of these cards was, and often the demand was overstated; such is very easy to do with there is limited information about the supply and demand of an object.

When eBay came around, it destroyed that market illusion by showing the market that the supply was much greater than anyone thought and the demand was actually much lower than anyone thought. It provided a superior means of determining supply and demand (ergo price), ultimately benefiting consumers at the expense of those who had been stockpiling sports cards on the false belief that these things would be valuable at some point in the future.

Now apply to law. What does good legal representation cost? Aside for the more "routine" services (simple chapter 7, llc drafting, basic real estate transactions, etc.), no one has a damned clue. Indeed, the ambiguity involved in legal representation - the fear that lawyer costs may skyrocket - inhibits a lot of people from seeking attorney aid. And when someone sits down with a lawyer in a one-on-one setting after a consultation, the potential client lacks any power to bargain if the lawyer says his services cost $200.00 an hour.

This set-up is a market illusion, just as the baseball card market was before eBay. The consumer (client) has no idea what the actual supply of legal services is. The lawyer is thus in a superior position to argue that his particular services are in high demand and short supply, even if they aren't.

If there were a reverse auction site set-up - not just this Shpoonkle thing, but also LawyerBid is in the game - prices for everything worth taking except the most complex litigation will drop. Why? Because lawyers are a competitive bunch and there are more licenses floating around than are necessary to service the current demand for legal services. People are, overall, cheapskates. If one barred lawyer can represent someone for half the price of another - and the individual can see the cost savings in black-and-white - that consumer isn't going to care who went to Harvard and who went to Cooley.

This is the nation of Wal-Mart and McDonalds. Prestige has nothing on cost savings, and not even Fortune 500 companies will turn down lower legal fees if they're clearly being overcharged. Right now, there's a market illusion that keeps people from seeing that they're being overcharged. If an auction site were set up, that illusion is gone.

This, of course, would be great for notions of "justice" and providing access to new parties, but, you see, the people at the high end are obviously worried. Or just ethically-minded attorneys in general. From Simple Justice:
By no means does the need for money make this a justifiable mechanism. It is anathema to what the legal profession is supposed to stand for, implicates a wide variety of unpleasant ethical considerations and reflects a further step, maybe giant step, away from excellence toward commodity. Yet my fear is that the lawyers who would sign up for this mutt couldn't care less.
...
I find it hard to blame some anonymous entrepreneurial law student from putting together this horrible idea. He's just trying to make a buck, and the creation of this new concept doesn't compel lawyers to sign up, lawyers to outbid each other to see how low they can go, lawyers to try to glom up cases in areas where they lack competency or lawyers to provide less than stellar services. It doesn't require that things go horribly wrong. But we all know they will.
That's my gut reaction as well, but let's face some facts. Law's professionalism went out the window a long time ago. The profession is now over saturated with 15k excess graduates every year in a market that is threatened to shrink by both outsourcing and technological advances.

And yet, attorneys at the top of the food chain still make a very good living, both the BigLaw partners and those working is solo firms at so-called "boutiques." There are absurd inefficiencies and market illusions harming consumers while the practitioners most burdened by the oversupply of attorneys is carrying a disproportionately heavy amount of non-dischargable debt acquired by entering the "profession."

Real professions don't set up situations such as that. Instead, they regulate who can enter the profession in order to ensure that there are few licensed professionals who struggle to make a living or pay off the costs of join the profession. The legal profession discarded that principle when it opened law school to any Joe and Betty with a 150 LSAT and a federal loan application. It cannot now hide behind professionalism as a shield to keep normal business conditions for penetrating every inch of the "profession" in a veiled attempt to keep billable hour rates unduly high.

At some point, something has to give.

I don't think this site will be a success. Indeed, as Simple Justice points out, other sites like this have failed previously, and I see too many ethical hurdles that may kill this site, especially if bar associations start looking after their interests and prohibit participation in these sites to maintain illusive values.

But people can't live in the dark forever, and you can't keep pumping out attorneys (i.e. supply) without prices, and therefore salaries, collapsing at some point. Maybe reverse auctions won't do it, but something will accelerate the race to the bottom that can already been seen in some areas.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Eric Holder Takes the Bullcrap Express to Montana

From The Missoulian:
U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder suggested that students at University of Montana's School of Law opt for careers in public service, urging them to consider "what we owe to our community, to our country and our fellow citizens."

"Today I call on each of you to choose action, to choose compassion," Holder said Wednesday.
What a load of schlocky crap.

First of all, although I've heard this weary refrain spouted from God knows how many self-righteous judges and professors, I've never once heard any sound justification for it beyond assuming the conclusion (i.e., that lawyers just "owe" non-attorneys and should bless them with public service).

Second, paid public service jobs are in incredibly high demand. Government and public service organizations turn away people who really want to work in public service all the time, so there's really no reason to "call" on people to work there, unless, of course, he expects people to work for free.

The legal profession "owes" absolutely nothing to the community, or the country, or our fellow citizens. In fact, many attorneys wouldn't be able to represent their clients well if they felt any kind of debt to society. Because law school is not a public service training ground. It is a professional service training ground. If you happen to represent the government, then your interests coincide. If you represent BP or a health insurance company, they probably do not.

But why do people like Holder (and, unfortunately, the people who run bar associations) continually think that lawyers should, as a normative value, give away their service for nothing? Why do lawyers owe more of a duty to the pubic than doctors, dentists, plumbers, grocers, farmers, auto repairmen, electricians, or any one else with specialized knowledge? Lawyers are no better suited for non-judge/AG public service than successful businessmen. Why are they especially "called?" Because the elites just decided that we collectively have this duty that they don't have the time to do themselves? Because it gives a feeling of elitism to be able to give your service away for free while 1/3 of your recent professional entrants have no work? Because elite lawyers want to believe - falsely - that they control access to justice?

I'm lost as to why people like Holder find it even remotely appropriate to tell trainees with 50k+ in debt and no jobs lined up that they have a duty to give back what they don't even yet (and may never) have, especially when it's to their collective economic disadvantage.

But that wasn't all for Holder.
Holder's talk marked the kickoff of the law school's centennial year, and he used it to highlight another anniversary, the swearing-in a half-century ago of Robert F. Kennedy as U.S. attorney general at the age of 35.

"I have been thinking a great deal about that moment and the extraordinary years of ballot drives, freedom rides, free schools and civil rights breakthroughs that soon followed it," he said.

Such activism, he said, "may be America's oldest - and perhaps finest - tradition. Since our nation's earliest days, young people - and, specifically, young lawyers - have been using their knowledge and training to stand up for justice."

Um...yeah. Okay, first of all, Robert Kennedy didn't have much to do with anything that actually happened in the 60s. Top-down civil rights initiatives, yes. Cuban Missile Crisis - yes, he more or less handled that. A great politician? Absolutely, but it's nothing more than mythmaking to give him credit for "the extraordinary years . . . that soon followed." Brown v. Board and Cooper v. Aaron were already done years before Kennedy was in the national spotlight. The foundations of the civil rights movements were in the 50s. And considering the politics of the time, I can't see an alternative Nixon administration and/or other A.G. doing a damn thing differently regarding the freedom riders or the other developments in the early 60s. And all of that would have happened with or without "young lawyers" who aren't particularly trained "to stand up for justice." (Who, except a vapid tool, has to be "trained" to stand up for justice, if that's their calling?)

It's such a blatantly egocentric view, i.e., "the guy in my shoes was a huge part of that," the implication being that Holder is something much more than he is.

But not everyone was trained to be so skeptical to see Holder's words as such blatant bullcrap.

First-year law student Dustin Leftridge of Missoula said he found Holder's message "incredibly inspirational."

"A call to service by the attorney general" dovetailed perfectly with his own idea of success in the legal profession, Leftridge said. "It's much more than somebody with a flashy Corvette and a nice suit."

Good God. I don't even know what to say.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Past ABA "Top Dog" Seeking So. Carolina Dean's Position

Something called Fitsnews has a rather interesting write-up criticizing University of South Carolina Board member William Hubbard for seeking the position of dean at South Carolina's law school.
William C. Hubbard . . . wants the job so bad that he is reportedly pressuring his fellow board members to rally behind his candidacy – while at the same time exploring ways to remain on the board while he serves in his new role.
...
Hubbard is no friend to the taxpayers of this state. Over his 24-year tenure on the USC board – including four years as chairman of the board – he has subjected students and parents to massive tuition increases. This money has gone to fund an unprecedented expansion of the school’s snowballing “mission” – including unnecessary duplication of existing programs, numerous unnecessary new programs and the spectacular failure of so-called “economic development” projects.
...
As one of the top dogs with the American Bar Association (ABA), Hubbard was reportedly instrumental in helping our state’s notoriously corrupt S.C. Supreme Court evade responsibility for its deliberate manipulation of a 2008 ABA investigation into its controversial attorney discipline system.
Wow, sounds perfect, doesn't he?

Saturday, January 8, 2011

Administrative Hypocrisy Rampant in NYT Article

Wow. For those who haven't seen it, the NY Times (David Segal) has done a seven-page article on the problems with law school (the law school "scam"). Special recognition to Kimber at SMS is owed for her presence and role in the piece. BIDER and JJD have already commented on the article, and there's little I can add to either their commentary or the article itself on its basic idea.

But I do want to call some of the administrative hypocrites in the article out for what they are, as it seems that part of the article may get lost in taking in the whole seven pages while people digest the enormity of having the problem showcased in the NYT. Considering the administrators in isolation shows why change to the current system must come from the outside, as the law school administrators become too biased in maintaining the status quo that benefits them. I think this is a point that needs to be made explicitly.

I greatly respect the work of Mr. Segal, so I'm going to borrow as minimally as possible to make my point, and I encourage all my readers to go to the Times and read the entire article; it's absolutely worth it.

First up is Beth Kransberger, associate dean at Thomas Jefferson School of Law (one of the law schools who occasionally advertise on this site via cheap google ads), who offered this:
[She] stands by [their 92% employment] figure, noting that it includes 25 percent of those graduates who could not be located, as well as anyone who went on to other graduate studies — all perfectly kosher under the guidelines....

“You need to take the high road,” she said. “Schools that are behaving the most ethically want students who come to law school with their eyes open."

Ms. Kransberger, you know very well that less than 25% of the non-respondents are employed, don't you? And you realize that graduate school is not the same thing as a remunerative job, right? So if you really want to "take the high road" and give students enough information to keep "their eyes open" as they enter law school, why are you adding them in?

No one cares about the "guidelines" except the USNWR people and the ABA. Students need to know how many of your respondents are actually employed as lawyers or at work similar in prestige and pay. "Schools . . . behaving . . . ethically" do not include an arbitrary figure of non-respondents as "employed" merely to boost their numbers, regardless of what the guidelines say what you can and can't do. You also should not be including baristas at Starbucks to behave "ethically." As a lawyer (I presume), you should know that law and ethics do not always align. As a legal educator, you should not be mistaking compliance with the law with moral behavior.

Next up is Phillip Closius, now dean at the University of Baltimore School of Law, who manipulated where low-LSAT students were placed to cause his former employer, Toledo, to shoot up in the rankings. He gets on the list with one paraphrased, self-explanatory sentiment:

In his estimation, a dean who pays attention to the U.S. News rankings isn’t gaming the system; he’s making the school better.
...as if the average student could tell one lick of difference in the education he or she received because the school's USNWR rating shot up 50 spots. On the previous page of the article, Dean Closius had said there were fallacies in the USNWR rankings; now he says following them makes the school better, which is an admission that they have value, which would suggest they are not based on fallacies. Make up your mind.

Next is Dean Yellen at Loyola, who gave this revelation:

...I do know that a lot of schools are hyping a lot of misleading statistics.
Yes, Dean Yellen . . . LIKE YOUR OWN!

Finally we have Yellen's cross-town rival David Greenberger, associate dean at DePaul, who added this:

I think [prospective students] should have all the info, and the info should be accurate, but saying once they know that they shouldn’t be allowed to come, that’s predicated on the idea that students are really ignorant and don’t know what is best for them.
Dean Greenberger, if this is what you believe, why does your school not give "all the info" and why is it not accurate?

Take a look at the following, directly from DePaul's prospective student profile in its admissions department:

Employment & Career Services Information

In 2009, 92.8% of the graduating class reported employment within nine months of graduation. While most DePaul graduates choose to stay in Illinois, specifically in Chicago, many choose to practice in other states. Popular employment locations for 2009 DePaul graduates include California, Indiana, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, Washington, DC, and Wisconsin..


Employment Categories

Private Practice 50%
Business 26.1%
Government 12.1%
Public Interest 4.4%
Judicial Clerkships 1.5%
Academia 4.4%
Unknown 1.5%

Salary Statistics

Average Starting Salary in Private Practice $97,056
Average Starting Salary in Business $74,267
Total Starting Salary Range $25,000-190,000

That's it for the website. What in the hell does any of this tell the average prospective student?

Anyone who's taken even an elementary course in statistics knows that an average is not a good measurement for data like this, as they are more susceptible to being skewed by outliers (like the $190,000 graduates) than a median.

What does "business" mean? Is stocking shelves at Costco "business?" How does one know anything by knowing the "average starting salary in business?" Is that all non-J.D. positions, or is it consulting and sales gigs? Is it J.D.-required jobs serving as inside counsel for major corporations?

What does it mean to say "92.8% of the graduating class reported employment within nine months of graduation." Is that permanent employment or do temporary gigs count, i.e., if they were employed for a 2-week gig during the nine month period? Is it really ALL graduates, or just survey respondents (ABA guidelines would suggest it's just survey respondents). Is it legal employment or non-legal employment? How many people even responded to the survey about their salaries? Obviously, if you had at least 7.2% unemployed, your salary range should be 0-$190,000, right?

To Dean Greenberger, I have no problem with the attitude in the latter half of your quote, but the students must have sufficient information first. Unless people like you and Dean Yellen start at home and have your own schools providing accurate, helpful information, your words are meaningless. It's one thing to talk about full and accurate information; get off your butt and do it. Set an example for your peers and the rest of the legal community and push for change in the ABA.

Until then you are nothing but another hypocrite spitting out empty buzz-words and platitudes trying to thrust blame on someone else. You have the power to change the system.

But unfortunately, as the article suggests (notably by Prof. Henderson), change is not likely to come from that quarter. There are at least six law school administrations mentioned or quoted in the article (including Georgetown's) and not a damned one of them comes off as defending anything of virtue. The quoted non-administrator professors all know what they're talking about and as far as I recall, each one puts a hammer to a nail. Something must change when you become an administrator; either that or the wrong people get promoted to that type of work.

These are the people who are to lead the next generation of lawyers, a field where ethical considerations are paramount. If they cannot perform their jobs without blatant hypocrisy or a confusion of ethics with following some silly guidelines, it speaks volumes about the state of legal education, as well as the ability of the profession to self-regulate.

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Dumb Unethical New Attorneys is a Symptom, Not the Disease

As you've probably heard, there is an ongoing crisis not only with the wave of foreclosures, but how the foreclosures have been processed and handled in some areas, with rampant reports of fraud, incomplete documents, etc. You'll never guess what trait various investigative parties have noted about the attorneys who handled foreclosures in Florida:
Today, more than 260 attorneys work at four of Florida's largest foreclosure firms, and 48 percent of them have been practicing law for less than three years, according to Florida Bar records obtained by The Palm Beach Post.
...
With this fall's allegations of forged foreclosure documents, fraudulent notarizations and questionable affidavits submitted in tens of thousands of foreclosure cases, those nascent lawyers are now under a cloud of suspicion.

Some may face Florida Bar investigations that could end their careers, while homeowner advocates wonder whether the foreclosure crisis would have reached its state of disorder if it weren't for legions of novice lawyers doing the legwork.

Maybe I'm a bit naive, but something tells me that if you don't know using a forged affidavit or notarization is a bad thing on day one, you're probably not cut out to be an attorney. That said, it seems obvious that the Post was looking for a headline-grabbing scapegoat here and found one in youth rather than the system itself.

This becomes readily apparent if you read the whole article, which few did when newspapers were real and even fewer do online. Some select quotes:

  • Lack of experience could have led young lawyers to follow their employer's lead, unaware they may be committing an offense....
  • Florida Bar President Mayanne Downs said the Tallahassee-based group has no power to open its own inquiries....
  • [A former young attorney involved in foreclosures] said Stern's practice was driven by paralegals, who prepared most of the paperwork. "If there was shady stuff being done, it was being done without our knowledge," he said....
  • Even so, Downs said Bar leaders are generally concerned with the education of Florida's young attorneys. With 11 law schools in the state, she said there is a question about whether there are too many programs producing lower-caliber lawyers....
  • Downs suspects most cases the Bar investigates will result in blame being placed on a number of factors, including overwhelmed lenders, overworked firms and lack of oversight.

I wonder if Mayanne Downs has learned not to talk to reporters. In so many words, she told the entire world that her organization has no power to independently investigate dishonest firms, that the investigations they currently have will likely be blamed on factors other than unethical attorneys, and that the state's legal education may be in such disrepair that unqualified attorneys are being admitted to the bar her association is supposed to oversee.

That's the real problem here, isn't it? Sure, desperate, dumb young attorneys are a part of the mess, but that's not the headline here. The fact that there is a large mass of young attorneys desperate to do any kind of attorney work is a product of there being too many law graduates. Foreclosure mills and other legally-dubious enterprises can exist in such an atmosphere because the young attorneys - no matter how ethical they may be themselves - have little incentive to ask questions or look into what they're signing. One who takes the time to fulfill ethical obligations in any sort of idealistic sense is back to the unemployment line rather quickly. In a sense, it's the basic model of pre-unionized factories and 3rd-world sweatshops.

You could throw the book at the inexperienced attorneys who signed these fraudulent things, but in the end that's really only addressing a symptom. As long as there's a dirt cheap supply of competitive labor, you're playing right into the hands of shysters and exploiters because you've set up a system where an imbalance of power means the firm owners have a sort-of ethical monopoly. If the firm wants to discard legal ethics in the name of profit and take the risk, what prompts the young associate to say "no," if there's little other chance of a job and a 100k in student debt to pay off? If they say "no," eventually someone will say yes. If they report it to the authorities, there may be an investigation that results in the firm losing business, leaving the associate out of work.

Ultimately, bar associations are supposed to be the guardians against this type of situation by controlling the access of who gets to be an attorney in the first place. The fact that this situation happened isn't primarily the fault of young attorneys or even poor education, it's the fault of a system of bar associations (state and national) that has proven to be utterly ineffective at regulating the attorney profession, which has led to a drastic oversupply of attorneys and all associated problems. This is merely one of them; it is not the first apparent problem and it will not be the last.

Friday, December 24, 2010

News Roundup: Virtech Paralegal, Suing McDonalds, Debt Collections, and Merry Christmas!

Our first item up today is Virtech Paralegal, a company based out of Dallas that seeks to reduce economies-of-scale advantages held by bigger law firms by making it easier for solo practitioners and small firms to access paralegal services and organizational software. I saw this today about the company:
Last month, Virtech landed its first private financing – $500,000 from a local angel investor group – for marketing and to hire up to 40 people, said Brandon Lloyd, co-founder and chief operating officer of Virtech. Almost all of Virtech's nearly 20 clients are sole practitioners, he said.
...
Beyond its recent angel financing, Virtech plans to raise $2.5 million in a private stock offering to expand to new markets, enhance its software and hire more staff, officials said.
...
First Virtech plans to expand its paralegal service to Austin, Houston, San Antonio, and to other states, starting with California next year, Brown said.
Now, I don't think this company's model is going to revolutionize the legal industry or bring BigLaw to its knees or anything like that, but that's a lot of financing and a lot of planned growth for a young company. Reading between the lines, I'm guessing that their numbers are very good for them to nab to 500k and then turn around and discuss a stock offering for five times as much, with expansion to other markets within two years. Either these people are expansion/credit-crazy to a fault and their business will come crashing down faster than a housing bubble eating Krispy Kremes, or their model is showing some very good returns thus far and proving itself better than whatever else is out there. My gut says the latter and that this is a situation to watch in lowering costs for private practitioners.
--------------------------------------
Our next item up is McDonalds and yet another example of someone taking products liability/tort/trade practices/etc. theories obviously too far. I don't think this really needs comment:
The Center for Science in the Public Interest is representing the mother of a six-year-old girl in a class-action lawsuit on behalf of all California children under the age of eight who have been exposed to McDonald's "inherently deceptive and unfair" marketing in the last three years. The suit claims that McDonald's has "engaged in a highly sophisticated scheme to use the bait of toys to exploit children's developmental immaturity and subvert parental authority" and that arguments over Happy Meals have caused "needless and unwarranted dissension in their parent-child relationship."
--------------------------------------
Our third item is debt collectors. For the uninformed, the FTC has passed through a number of changes in debt collection law in the wake of the omnibus financial reform that took place last year, specifically to target deceptive practices. But as with all things where laws cannot cover the full gamut of clever means to the ultimate end, Creditbloggers reports that debt collectors are finding novel solutions. This one struck me in particular:
Another tactic: Pose as lawyers, who are exempted from the new rules. By setting themselves up as law firms, many debt resolution companies believe they can skirt the rules. But few consumers actually get to speak to a real lawyer, according to the letter, and if they do, the lawyer is usually not licensed to practice law in their state.
I would hope there's no attorneys dumb enough to set up these firms that exist solely to evade the law and perform what seems to me to be the unauthorized practice of the law, but I'm sure we'll be seeing more stories on this in the future. There's too much money involved in debt collection - especially as joblessness continues - for there to not be entertaining shenanigans in the murky debt collection sector.
--------------------------------------
The fourth item is that I want to wish all my readers who celebrate it a Merry Christmas!

Friday, November 19, 2010

The Lohans Attorneys Should Go To Rehab, Too

Don't count on this space becoming a receptacle of celebrity gossip, but I read this today and thought it was worth comment.

Dina Lohan is allegedly having her lawyers draft a bitter, nasty letter to the creators of Glee, who on Wednesday night's episode apparently mocked her daughter Lindsay by saying "Linsday is totally crazy" and "Lindsay has been to rehab 5 times." She explained: "“Our lawyers are sending a letter” to 'Glee' on the grounds that the show allegedly defamed the actress who, by all accounts, is working hard on her recovery." A rep for Lohan adds, “Lindsay has an issue that millions of people around the world are dealing with yet ‘Glee’ is treating addiction as a laughing matter.”

Um... what do you think the creators of Glee and their lawyers are going to do with said letter? Treat it seriously and publicly recant? There's no defamation claim here whatsoever. Any celebrity who's intelligent and took a 5-minute crash course would know that.

My point of bringing this up is that I'm curious about the lawyers sending out this letter. In an ideal universe, they would look her in the eye and tell her she's making an ass of herself. In the 2nd-most ideal universe, they would draft a letter explaining the harm caused and courteously requesting that Glee apologize and stop future assaults on her character. But the first makes no money and the second is something Dina could presumably do herself, so the lawyers have every incentive to claim a highfalutin legal cause of action, defamation.

This sort of civil-lawyers-as-belligerent-bulldogs nonsense, especially when employed by public figures is one of the reasons why people hate attorneys. In some jurisdictions, a lawyer can face criminal extortion charges for making meritless legal demands. Maybe that's too far, but certainly the bar associations could be more aggressive in regulating this type of behavior, as it does impugn the profession as a whole to have attorneys sending out letters with no plausible claim behind them. Like in the U.K. (although I think this situation would probably also trigger action in the U.S.)