Showing posts with label accreditation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label accreditation. Show all posts

Monday, May 23, 2011

Chinese Law School(s) Revisited

Law.com has a nice update on the continued attempt by the Peking University School of Transnational Law to gain accreditation. The entry basically boils down to a back-and-forth between sense and nonsense. For example, this makes sense:
"This proposal makes absolutely no sense, unless we just want to implode the legal field in the United States and get our unemployment rate in the double digits for decades to come."
This, however, makes no sense:
With barely 50 students set to graduate in its first class in 2012, compared to the more than 4,000 foreign lawyers who take the New York bar each year, STL could have little impact on the U.S. job market, even if it sent that class en masse to America.
It's clear that this isn't a story about this one extra-national school gaining accreditation; it's about setting a precedent whereby the ABA will accredit extra-national schools, which would lead to a plethora of institutions popping up in India, China, Brazil, Eastern Europe, you name it, all in the name of selling American legal educations to rising economic players on the cheap.

And it completely ignores that the sole reason for a school like this seeking accreditation is so that it's graduates can sit for the bar exam in U.S. jurisdictions.

Furthermore, the willful ignorance by Dean Jeffrey Lehman is alarming:

But if the ABA is ultimately swayed by arguments about the bad U.S. job market for lawyers, Lehman thinks that the organization should be forthright about it.

"Then the ABA should announce they aren't accrediting any more law schools anywhere because there are too many lawyers," he says.

Right, because there's no difference between a Chinese law school and an American law school...

Contrary to what these capitalist blockhead superheroes want to claim, the purpose of an American law school is to train lawyers to work in the American legal system. It is not to ensure that people in foreign countries are learning western values or any other nonsense. There is no logical reason that training for American lawyers should be done in China, and there are valid reasons to prohibit such activity even if it offers economic benefits for the chosen few who run the system. On the plus side, however, this may be the one issue where American law professors are (or should be) on the same side as the jaded students. If legal training is exported, the gravy train and the six-figure salaries vanish.

If the ABA accredits this operation while maintaining its entry barriers that prohibit domestic innovation (e.g., online-intensive law schools, insistence on a tenured faculty, etc.), we'll truly know that the organization has no interest in actually serving the interests of American law.

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Comments On The Latest Troll

This morning, I found, perhaps, the dumbest comment I've ever received on this blog:
You are no better than the elite that run this country.

Let me get this straight, if you were queen of the world you would ONLY allow the uber-smart people attend law school? Does is stop with law school? Or is this a general application of all fields of studies? Practicing law is not as glamorous as you purport it to be.

Personally, I have much more respect for someone that can plumb a house than another who can properly apply the facts to the elements of manslaughter.

You blog is nothing more than pseudo-intellectual masturbation. sickening.

Disgusting. Really.
I don't even know where to start with this troll, but I feel the idiocy therein leads to a few talking points:

1. "Let me get this straight, if you were queen of the world you would ONLY allow the uber-smart people attend law school?" Absolutely not! As actual readers of the blog know, I have very little regard for the LSAT, even though I did well on it. If an institution can admit people with moderate intelligence and achieve a high bar passage rate with a real positive return on investment, I would welcome it. For example, I think the University of South Dakota is a good law school, all things considered, even with its low median LSAT; I would recommend an in-state student go there instead of any number of "higher ranked" schools.

The problem with LaVerne is that it's not performing up to par with peer institutions. If it could admit 148 LSATs and put out a bar passage rate equal to Loyola, UC-Davis, etc., then I'd have no problem with it. But they aren't doing that, so their continuance of accepting 148 LSATs should warrant skepticism.

2. "Does is stop with law school? Or is this a general application of all fields of studies?" I think all post-graduate education should be ultimately governed by economic principles. Law is only unique to the extent that the government continues to authorize the antitrust behavior of the ABA.

3. "Practicing law is not as glamorous as you purport it to be." I have never claimed law to be a "glamorous" field. I actually object to the way law schools perpetuate the myth. Dignity and glamor are two entirely different concepts.

4. "Personally, I have much more respect for someone that can plumb a house than another who can properly apply the facts to the elements of manslaughter." I would say both are fully competent in their chosen professions, and that there's not much more that can be said. I think many students today would be better off as plumbers than as lawyers, but that doesn't mean a lawyer's work is not valuable. It absolutely is, in most cases.

All I'm advocating is that some type of standards be put in place to protect consumers from the perils of a bubble that produces heaps of non-dischargable debt and lost opportunity costs. Or, rather, to prevent further damage. As far as I'm concerned, this can take one of two shapes:

1. Market-based regulation, where the ABA loses its monopoly, the federal government stops back-stopping loans, barriers to entry are removed, and schools can compete like actual businesses. The overall cost of a law license would drop dramatically as schools would no longer have to follow ABA guidelines, but instead could sell a glorified long-term bar preparation courses to whomever wanted to buy. Plus, rising tuition would be checked by the fact that schools could no longer rely on Uncle Sam's thriftless loan policies.

2. Profession-based regulation, where the ABA keeps its monopoly, but it and state bar associations enforce more rigorous training and accreditation standards, enforce transparency regulations to ensure schools are being honest with students, force schools to audit their recent employment information, etc. The gist here is that the ABA would take active steps to prevent the massive oversupply of young attorneys who are misled into poor investments and/or unsustainable debt loads by gaining a pigeonholed credential in an oversaturated field.

The two obviously aren't mutually-exclusive.

Friday, May 20, 2011

More on La Verne College of Law's Accreditation

La Verne College of Law has received official notice from the ABA (by way of a 14-page letter; did this really take 14 pages?) that its accreditation committee recommended denying La Verne because of low bar passage rates.

This shouldn't surprise anyone when a school's bar passage rate is less than 70% after the 2nd try and the 1st try takers lag behind the state's other schools.

But of course, Dean Allen Easley has a defense/excuse: "we need more time!"
"We think that they've misunderstood some of the facts," Easley said of the committee's recommendation. "They have not given enough weight to all the changes we've made that are likely to produce better results in the future."

Making the requirements for admittance and grading more stringent could take years to show results, he said, adding that the university has also improved its legal-writing program and revamped its third-year bar exam support course.

You've had five years. Is that not the point of "provisional" accreditation, to give a school time to make adjustments before it becomes a fully-accredited institution? What were you doing in those five years? You had 3 full cycles of students. Why weren't these adjustments made already, as in 2-3 years ago? Or - if you had any institutional pride six years ago - after your 2005 class only had a 32% first-time pass rate? And where are these "more stringent" criteria for admissions? You're still apparently admitting kids with 148-150 LSATs. This kid and his/her 149/3.2 (public school poli sci) allegedly got $11,000 in scholarship money.

And let's not forget that the 1L transfer rate is over 17%. At least in my opinion, 1L attrition is a fairly solid indicator of the value of a school. Using LSN's numbers, the following schools are all over 20%: Florida Coastal, Cooley, Barry, St. Thomas (Florida), Cal-Western, Touro (37%!), Western New England, Jones/Faulkner, Liberty, Nova Southeastern, Oklahoma City, Detroit-Mercy, Valparaiso, Western State, Widener, Willamette, Florida International, and Golden Gate. I omitted Whitter because it was on probation at the time, and I probably missed one or two others. All of those are fully-accredited, and it reads as a who's who of poorly-regarded law schools. I think the ABA made a poor decision giving full accreditation to Jones/Faulkner and Liberty and I think any school that has 20+% of its students leave after the first year should be placed on automatic probation.

I'm also wondering how "more stringent" curves will make bar exam pass rates rise. What exactly is the thesis here? They'll force more drop-outs? That getting a C- in Torts instead of a C+ will make Joe Schmo study more?

Here's to hoping the ABA denies full accreditation. Sorting out the law school bubble will be no cut-and-dry task, but an ABA that enforces standards and refuses to add more schools to the mess is a positive step.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Update on U. of La Verne Accreditation; ABA Recommends Denial

So as it turns out, one of the most popular entries on this blog recently has been my entry from January on the University of La Verne, where I discussed their provisional accreditation status. As far as google keywords go, "La Verne" is up near the top, somehow topping the lost porno searchers (seriously, if you're googling "pornography" and you wind up here, you epically failed; also, my hits for this entry will skyrocket as a result of using the word "pornography" multiple times. go me).

As it turns out, the ABA's accreditation committee is recommending a denial of full accreditation to La Verne. According to this article, a final decision will come June 11, after the ABA Council issues its finding on whether it accepts the recommendation or denies it, and whether La Verne will continue to have provisional accreditation if denied. La Verne will have a chance to present its argument for accreditation, but it seems they're not overly optimistic:
"There's a pretty good chance that we won't get full approval because the odds are stacked against us right now," said Allen K. Easley, the college's dean and professor.
...

During [a meeting last Wednesday with 150 concerned students], Easley said college officials were discussing the denial with their lawyers.

Meanwhile, officials said, the university is applying for state bar accreditation to ensure every current student will be able to take the exam after they graduate.

I would hope so, although I think "the" exam is faulty wording; it should be "a" bar exam. Rightfully, students are pissed.

"Even looking at this with the most likely and optimistic view of the school is that we're probably going to lose our accreditation in June," said Rachael Alcorn, 24.

"When I graduate in (May) 2012, I'm only going to have the California bar (and not ABA backing). That's not what I came to this school for."
...

Student Ali Kazmi, 25, of Rancho Cucamonga said he was trying to determine what his next move would be.

"It catches you off guard ... I'm worried about the school's reputation now," Kazmi said.

Well, it's not like the school had a stellar reputation to begin with, but I completely understand where these students come from. The ABA's course of action during the entire law school bubble was to "Always Be Accreditin'." It was a logical assumption to make that all provisionally-accredited would be fully-accredited in due time. The students couldn't have predicted the ABA would wake up and enforce standards, and so I think they have a right to be angry at the situation.

For example, here is what the 2010-2011 Course Catalog says about accreditation:

The University of La Verne College of Law has been provisionally approved by the Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar of the American Bar Association since February 13, 2006. The Section of Legal Education may be contacted at 321 North Clark Street, Chicago, IL 60610 or by phone at (312) 988-6738.

Provisional approval precedes full ABA approval. ABA policy states that students enrolled in a provisionally-approved school are entitled to all the rights and privileges as students at fully approved schools. A law school must remain in provisional status for a minimum of two years before becoming eligible for consideration for full approval.
Do you see that? It "precedes full approval" as if it's a given, a guarantee, an inevitable turn-of-the-page consequence. No mention of the chance that the ABA will say "no." No mention of the 5-year provisional expiration or the school's previous issue with low bar passage rates. That seems like misrepresentation of a material fact, and that's not right, La Verne.

Unfortunately, the students are the ones really getting screwed here. The school will go on, possibly as a state accredited institution, but that model seems to work in California and they'll have a better reputation than the other California-only schools. The students, however, are stuck with a J.D. from a non-ABA school, which means they can't practice in most states. Even though they'll be denied the benefit of an ABA-approved education, they'll still be paying the massive costs (I think it's around 36k a year). If La Verne loses 2012 accreditation, the Class of 2012 will be truly and royally screwed. Most law students severely overpay for a product. La Verne's 2Ls and possibly 3Ls will be overpaying for a product they can't even fully use.

So here are my pithy, but completely serious suggestions for all involved:

-If you're the ABA, make a rule or exception that allows students who enrolled at a provisionally accredited school to finish as if they'd gone to a provisionally-accredited school.

-If you're a 1L at La Verne in the top 1/3 or so of the class, transfer. For the love of all that's holy, get out of Dodge. If you're in the bottom 2/3, find something else to do with your life unless you have a warm seat waiting for you on the other side.

-If you're a 2L or 3L at La Verne, complain, protest, and spread awareness about the massive screwjob that the school and the ABA seem to be performing.

-If you're the La Verne administration or faculty, ask yourself why you're running an institution that charges around $36,000 a year for an education where students aren't even equipped to pass the bar, may not have a chance to even take the bar, and, even if they pass, are thrown into a saturated legal market that has almost no use for them.

Also, ask yourself why your school has been less-than-upfront about the possibility that the school would lose accreditation (see my previous entry, or the course catalog entry above) and why I'm not able to find up-front tuition and costs on the school's website. Are you hiding this information from prospective applicants? Are these the operational values that you want to be associated with?

Also, I honestly think the La Verne administration should seriously consider some type of rebates to students for the school's failure.

Overall, it's hard to not see La Verne as the epitome of the law school bubble. From the first article linked:
The college has 420 students, up from about 250 or so prior to it gaining provisional accreditation from the ABA, he said.
A 68% jump. Think students don't factor in accreditation? Think the school didn't advertise it to the max?

I have no connection to La Verne, and I know no one who's ever talked about the place, but it's hard to not blame the school in this situation. Hopefully, the school can retain provisional status, only to prevent a large amount of students from being doubly screwed. If the ABA leaves the school with no accreditation, I really hope they find a way to except the current 2Ls and 3Ls, because it's really not right leaving them as the hot potato victims of this mess.

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Massachusetts School of Law Dean at it Again

As Matt at LSTB has pointed out, Massachusetts School of Law associate dean Michael Coyne is back with another editorial about why the ABA model of law school education sucks. I dissected one of his editorials in January, noting that while I love his jabbing-at-the-ribs spirit, I think he still falls into the myth and propaganda division on many points. And this one's no different, although he does get some points for, at some level, calling ABA law school a "scam." I'm not even sure I would go that far.

This one has a better title than the first one: Law school for the white and wealthy, and it's in a better place than the Worcester Telegram (I wonder how often he shoots these invectives to newspapers?).

The first few paragraphs are exactly the same as his previous rant, but he's added a few things. To wit:
The fact that Massachusetts School of Law charged tuition that was less than half of what ABA law schools charge (today that figure stands closer to one-third) meant it threatened the ABA's reason for its existence: ensuring high fees for lawyers by charging exorbitant admissions fees to enter its exclusive club.
If there's one thing Americans love, it's lower prices. With law schools, we have a clear case of indirect price restraints set by a centralized organization. But that doesn't necessarily lead to "ensuring high fees for lawyers." Aside from fixed costs, the undersupply or oversupply of labor is what dictates service fees. Lawyers' fees have been in a race to the bottom in the last 20 years everywhere except the high-stakes corporate law of the largest firms. Profit margins on simple, straightforward legal tasks have dropped relative to inflation while law school tuition has risen sharply. If the ABA served to ensure high fees for lawyers, it's already failed.

And low tuition isn't really a direct threat to the ABA or its existence. The MSL wouldn't be in competition with the ABA. It would force other schools to slash prices or reevaluate their curricula, but the ABA could still serve as the gatekeeper without any functional change. The problem is that MSL's potential competitors - the Suffolks and even the Boston Colleges of the world - all lobby the ABA about how crucial their accreditation standards are, sometimes with genuine concerns and sometimes as a pretext to keep prices and salaries high.

Again, love the spirit, but the reasoning needs work. Appealing to high lawyers' fees seems like little more than baseless populism that isn't necessary in villainizing the ABA.

But there's more: Coyne continued playing the race card, now with a cited authority:
As law professor Vernellia Randall, a well-known public speaker on issues of health, race and representation of African-Americans in the legal profession, has noted, "Institutional discrimination in law schools is really about maintaining the legal profession as 'The Whitest Profession.' "
After referring off-offhandedly to Jim Crow (as if someone can offhandedly refer to Jim Crow), Coyne again noted that African-American enrollment has declined. Compelling stuff on its face, but again, this needs more explanation. How do the ABA standards keep the profession abnormally white? How do you explain the decline? Is it because of the tuition or just because of the culture of law school? Is the LSAT keeping qualified and willing African-American applicants out? Without these logical connections, Coyne looks like little more than a biased polemicist.

At least he ends on a bang:
So to the ABA: Spare us the kind words and coronets. Reform our higher education system now. Allow innovative, low-cost colleges and law schools to develop. Let those schools compete on an even footing with the barons in their ivy-towered campuses who preside over schools for students to whom money does not matter. Allow the graduates of all our law schools to take every state's bar examination and compete in the marketplace. Hope, opportunity and competition are what made this country great; they can do so again.
I think the English royalty metaphor is a bit trite and strained, but it's hard to argue with the rest of it. Once we've allowed capitalism to be the reigning force in the legal profession (and we hvae), nothing should stop law school from following suit. If you're going to keep it as a "profession," keep it as a profession in all regards, including limiting entry into the market. But once professionalism's gone (and it pretty much is), there's no reason lawyers can't be trained at schools like MSL so long as they pass the licensing requirements, especially if places like MSL actually can prepare people to practice better than the casebook method used by students at other schools.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Joseph Rakofsky: Both an Idiot and a Symptom

This entry was corrected for possible minor errors due to possible discrepancies I learned of during the week of May 16. A summary of the minor changes can be seen here.

Others have already commented on the Joseph Rakofsky story, but in reading commentary on the issue, I'm a bit bothered by how many people want to call him a moron and move on as if that's the end of the inquiry.

To refresh everyone's memory, Rakofsky, a 2009 Touro grad with very little actual experience, and a law license in New Jersey, decided to try a murder case in Washington, D.C. As one might expect, it did not go well, and multiple people, including the judge and the Washington Post courthouse reporter, found Rakofsky's performance a sign of "incompetence." I trust their judgment.

Is Joseph Rakofsky an idiot? Absolutely. Let us count the ways.

But he's also a symptom of one of the fundamental problems of attorney oversupply. Back in December, I pointed out that having a large mass of desperate unemployed attorneys can put ethical obligations into jeopardy in the context of foreclosure mills. There, attorneys looking for a job - any job - would have an incentive to sacrifice morals to bring in a paycheck.

Rakofsky is the Horatio Alger, "pull himself up by his bootstraps," side of that same coin.

Rokofsky's website is now down, but here is his "About Me" paragraph that I rescued from google cache:
Mr. Rakofsky has worked on cases involving Murder, Embezzlement, Tax Evasion, Civil RICO, Securities Fraud, Bank Fraud, Insurance Fraud, Wire Fraud, Conspiracy, Money Laundering, Drug Trafficking, Grand Larceny, Identity Theft, Counterfeit Credit Card Enterprise and Aggravated Harassment. Following graduation from law school, he worked for one of the biggest civil litigation firms on the east coast and has worked for boutique white-collar criminal defense firms in Manhattan. During law school, Mr. Rakofsky interned at the Legal Aid Society (in Suffolk County). Prior to studying law, Mr. Rakofsky studied Economics and interviewed at a well-respected investment bank with branches all over the world. Prior to law school, Mr. Rakofsky earned a Bachelor of Science in Biology, concentrating his attention on DNA.
Hey, my attention was concentrated on DNA too, specifically the kind at Tri-Delt. But I digress again.

It's clear that Rakofsky's bio is milking every minor experience he's ever had especially since he just graduated in 2009. Filed a service return for a credit card collection? Sounds like identity theft experience to me! But this is the monster we've created. The options for attorneys who can't find real jobs out of law schools are either to try something else, settle for doc review-type jobs, or set out on their own. Commentators often promote the idea of setting up shop as a viable alternative to getting a job, and many law school deans (Thomas Mengler, as one example) justify purposefully flooding the market by claiming that more solos and firms means lower prices and better lawyering (a really stupid conclusion, but that's for another day).

Well, here we have a kid who clearly wanted to do criminal law. He set up a slick website (financialcrimelaw.com; great url!) to make him look like the smooth legal hucksters on TV. He set up four offices. To account for his relative virginity, he listed every conceivable experience he could. Such is necessary to compete with the 40+ crowd who market their prematurely-gray hair like a badge of honor rather than a sign of stress.

Isn't this exactly what the Menglers of the world want him to do? Even if it isn't, is this not the natural result when you saddle kids with $100k+ in debt and pigeonhole them into an overcrowded field? Aren't they going to set up sleek websites and offer discounts and hope and pray that they make it through their first cases without looking like a doofus? After all ,can't have a gap on the resume. Must be working, getting out there, networking with other solos, gaining experience. Prior to last week, most industry apologists would have likely held up Rakofsky as an example of what unemployed law graduates should be doing, that they should be entrepreneurial.

But entrepreneurship is not good when the product being peddled is an inferior quality and public welfare is placed at risk. Rakofsky may not have even been aware that he was peddling an inferior product; he probably honestly believed he was competent, and such is part of the problem with a "Wild West" view of licensing, accrediting, and more or less forcing some graduates to solo it.

Everybody lost except the people at Touro who cashed his tuition checks. Everybody.

In medicine, graduates of medical school are not allowed to just "hang a shingle" and set up their own practices. They must go through a 3-5 year period called residency where they learn to actually practice medicine on real people in real hospitals. You are not allowed to become board certified and practice medicine without supervision until you have completed a residency program. All graduates of medical school programs are more or less guaranteed a space in a residency program because the medical profession actually cares about integrity and welfare and limits the output of medical schools. They made a sound policy decision to be cautious and prevent unprepared doctors from being unleashed on the public.

I hold no illusion that law is as important as medicine, but I completely fail to see how anyone in their right mind can continue to license attorneys to do things that they are entirely unqualified to do. Why is there not a residency requirement, or the equivalent? Changing law school to be two years of study and two-three years of low-paid study under a practicing attorney doesn't seem to be too big of a burden. Neither does requiring specialization or making the bar exam more practical to the actual day-to-day practice of law in a specific jurisdiction.

The system is completely broken. It cannot filter out people like Rakofsky; instead it allows them to flow through by the thousands and onto an unsuspecting marketplace. It has no training safeguards to ensure that people handling murder cases can actually handle murder cases. The more hubris-filled unemployed attorneys will do exactly what Rakofsky did; his story made the rounds, others' do not. But he is by no means unique. He is exactly what happens when you license type A personalities to do things before they've actually shown they can do it.

We do not license people to drive classes of vehicles they have never touched before. We do not license surgeons who have never held a scalpel. Yet in many cases attorneys can handle matters they know little about merely because they've duped some poor client into believing they're "the guy."

A real profession doesn't let that situation develop, and it stops the nonsense once it becomes apparent.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

AALS Desperate as Bubble Bursts, Seeks to Halt New Accreditation Standards

If there's one thing that's true when gravy trains end and organizations start shedding people, it's that the everyone suddenly will go to great lengths to explain how important they are.

Hence, a grossly overstated letter by the AALS to Hulett "Bucky" Askew regarding some proposed changes to the ABA's accreditation standards. Props to Paul Caron at TaxProfBlog for hosting it and pointing it out. I'm not going to reprint it all here, but I definitely encourage my readers to check it out for some light chuckles and some sterling examples of "begging the question" or "assuming the conclusion" logical fallacies.

For example, the letter characterizes the SRC's proposal as a "thought experiment" that may undermine the present legal education system. But one must ask: where is the proof justifying the structure of the current legal education system? Is it merely enough that we've done a thing a particular way for decades? I think not.

But that doesn't stop AALS from trying to justify its members' jobs.

Wow, where do I start? Probably by stating the obvious: this is bullshit. There is absolutely no empirical proof that the "scholarship and public service" allegedly carried out by full-time faculty "give [their teaching] an authority" that adjunct teachers cannot. None, nor is the valid reason to assume this. After all, if I have a choice between one professor who actually represents real people in the local federal court and another who hasn't seen a courtroom in 20 years, who is going to have more "authority" behind his teaching? Hint: it ain't the guy who writes journal articles on esoteric theory.

Honest to goodness, law is a professional school designed to teach professional skills. What student ever values someone more because they write an unread article or do public service? And why are adjuncts somehow foreclosed from such things? Many practitioners write more relevant articles than full-tenure professors, anyway, and there's no reason to believe a law professor is any more committed to public service than a non-professor.

"[O]nly full-time career faculty can be expected..." reeks of baseless elitism. To buy into this rhetoric, one would have to assume that there's something truly different about full-time faculty. The entire letter seems to assume this without any empirical proof and relying on dubious conclusions (e.g., that American legal education is "high quality") and outright misstatements (e.g., law is not a "fundamentally public profession").

The point of an American legal education is to train competent lawyers. There is no evidence, nor is there any logical reason to believe, that that goal necessarily requires a full-time tenured faculty. And they do demand their tenure, see p. 5: "[Full-time faculty] remind students of the clients who encounter law and the students' ethical obligations as lawyers, and they facilliate the process of learning about law, lawyers, and the meaning of justice." Again, this can't be done by part-time non-tenured faculty?

There are a variety of other sub-issues (like distance learning and the LSAT), but the gist is that the professors feel threatened by the contemplated changes:

Ah, yes, bureaucratic stalling. Of course, if there were any real discussion of "first principles," the law professors would lose, and badly. Law school is not a scientific academy or a liberal arts college; it is a professional school designed to train people who can actually walk into court and argue and file items on behalf of a client. There is no evidence whatsoever that such a process requires a robust full-time faculty of academics indistinguishable from their liberal arts peers aside from paycheck and the type of elitist condescension on display.

The real factor that "make[s] reform desirable" is that law professors don't actually teach students how to be lawyers. That's a "first principle." To hell with social justice and the "valuable" aspects of legal education if the law schools can't even do that.

Cost, of course, is another factor making broad reforms desirable. This system clearly is not sustainable, and professors that make $200k a year make a very sane target for cuts. But the AALS has a defense for this: it isn't the professors making double their value that increase costs, it's the students and the rascally people in the admissions department:

Translation: before cutting full-time staff, cut career services or scholarships!

Because basically what we have here is a ten-page letter full of fear and bold statements that is absolutely devoid of any substantive proof of what it's claiming. Full-time professors are supposedly just "better" than other options, more ethical, more service-oriented, and more apt to gain expertise (than, you know, the actual people filing claims in court). Most generic students, I suspect, wouldn't be able to tell a full-time tenured faculty member from a part-time adjunct.

All this is is raw, naked self-preservation wrapped in a coat of hollow rhetoric and baseless assumptions about how great legal education has been in the last few decades. I don't necessarily support all the standards changes, but I think they're a move in the right direction and the AALS' attempt to derail them in "let's do a study" hell is shameless and militates against any finding that organizations like the AALS exist for any "public service."

They're clearly not, or else this letter would look radically different.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Iowa Law Symposium In Review: No Motel 6's For These Deans

Matt at LSTB has run a review of the recent Iowa Law Review Symposium/masturbation for academic eunuchs concerning the future of legal education, which I had mentioned earlier. He reviews the Chronicle of Higher Education's commentary and the fallacies and the moral dubiousness certain administrators keep spouting amidst some sensible concessions and realizations. He also asked my opinion, which is a mistake almost no one makes, but here goes.

I don't want to rehash the same ground, because LSTB's run-down is fairly brief and gets the point across well, but - setting aside the moral issues - I wanted to focus on the theme of law school efficiency, tradition, and readiness for legal practice. Here are some relevant excerpts from the Chronicle's review:
One reason schools are sticking with a familiar playbook: "It's a cost-effective method of education," Mr. Chemerinsky said.
...
Richard A. Matasar, dean of New York Law School, summed up the attitude he sees at many campuses: "We're all old dogs trying to learn some new tricks, and all of us old dogs have got tenure and we're not going any place."
...
Legal education does cost too much, Mr. Matasar said, mainly because it is "grossly inefficient." Schools could cut costs by stratifying—offering, as a friend characterized it to him, a "Motel 6" education with few bells and whistles, in which practicing lawyers teach many of the courses, as well as a "Ritz-Carlton" version taught by full-time, tenure-track professors. Neighboring schools could share library, faculty, and other resources, he said, adding, "Does every law school need an expert in the law of Timbuktu?"
...
Gail B. Agrawal, dean of law at the University of Iowa, cautioned that law schools should be careful, as they shift their emphasis toward practical skills like drafting motions and interviewing clients, that they don't shortchange broader goals, such as cultivating a commitment to social justice.
Reading through these responses conjured up two main streams of thought: (1) this is exactly the type of predictable "the sky's the limit"/"but we have so much to do" worthless-at-the-end-of-the-day dialogue I expected; (2) this is exhibit A as to why self-regulation is a bad idea for legal education.

From a student view, who in the hell would choose a non-elite "Ritz-Carlton" (a.k.a. "Undergrad II") law school model? I would think that student demand would be to actually learn how to draft legal documents, file motions, argue at hearings, and - you know - make money as a practicing attorney. Frankly, it's derisive, ego-centric, and presumptuous to call the tenured professor model the "Ritz-Carlton" and the efficient, functional model the "Motel 6." Is it really a "luxury" to learn the Rule in Shelley's Case?

In other words, given a choice at equal cost between a Ritz-Carlton and Motel 6, everyone would take the Ritz. Given a choice at equal cost between a functional, trade-type law school and an Undergrad II model, I would think 2/3+ would prefer the former, since I'm 95% certain that that school's graduates would succeed and be more employable than those who got a less-hands-on education.

But the casebook-Socratic method thrives. For one, it is, as Dean Chemerinsky asserts, cost-effective from the schools' point of view. From the students' point of view, it isn't effective at all (i.e., they're not even getting the product they paid for). And I take issue with the idea that teaching practical skills is inherently more expensive. Setting up a formal law clinic or an advocacy course, yes, that's expensive. But so is having an Israeli Law and Policy seminar with 5 students in it, and so is paying Professor Bookworm 250k to be an expert on arcane applications of federal procedure.

But if you're going to have a class called, say, Constitutional Law, why not look at actual Con Law cases and arguments made in the past 5 years? Why do they do an anguishing review of commerce clause cases from the 1930s? Do a brief intro and go straight to Lopez, Morrison, and Raich. Are the Lottery Case and the Shreveport Rate Case interesting? I suppose. Would anything of real value to practicing lawyers be lost? Nope. After all, when given a new topic to do legal research on, no one would ever start at square one. Why would you? We tell students in their first-year legal skills classes to go straight to Am. Jur. to figure out what's going on and yet, in the doctrinal classes, they start at time immemorial. Why, God, why?

But it's more than just professors being "old dogs." It's also that the ABA has built in a number of safeguards to ensure that this system will remain in place for a long time. They allude to this in the article, quoting Jay Connison, Valparaiso Dean and ABA Accreditation chairman, in saying that the ABA is looking into changing their standards. Of course that should have been done 20 years ago and probably won't be done now, but the deans are right when they say the ABA's standards limit their creativity. For example, read Standards section 4 and tell me how in the "Motel 6" model of law school is even possible. And how is a school supposed to share a library with section 6 in the way?

What I suspect Matasar knows full well is that such a vision is impossible under the ABA guidelines. And while deans may complain about the ABA guidelines publicly, they are the ones who run the show. You can't blame "the man" when you are "the man!" And despite Connison's words, nothing is going to change. Why would it? Deans are self-interested capitalists who love the Ritz-Carlton model. Do you think anyone makes six figures under a Motel 6 model? No, and no one gets to fly to Iowa to pontificate, either.

Thus, all of this mess comes back to the ABA's monopoly over national accreditation, which the deans - especially the vocal ones who seem to wind up at all these symposia - have power to change. So, they've essentially bound their own hands so they can cry about having their hands tied.

But because their restrictions require so much in the line of library resources, tenured faculty, scholarship, and all sorts of things that seem, to me, ancillary to legal education that they've effectively shut off price competition. It's a complex oligopoly. Instead of having price (tuition) stability, they let anyone compete against them, provided that they have the virtually the exact same expenditures (guaranteed by ABA regulations). This isn't how real business works, of course. In the "real world," there'd be "Motel 6" law schools everywhere by now. And as much as we joke about it, that wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing.

Business has a natural tendency towards efficiency. We're seeing that in law firms, as they integrate LPO and cost-cutting. If "Motel 6" law schools could generate 90% bar passage rates at do teaching students part-time at $15k total cost, who in the hell would care? As long as there are still ethical and admission standards that the ABA holds the schools to, the American justice system wouldn't suffer at all. If anything, the range of options available may cause consumers (prospective students) to actually research the places more and figure out which schools are good, which are bad, which produce results, etc.

If you cut the resource requirements to what is actually reasonable, the "Motel 6" schools would have an incentive to keep costs low in a way that current TTT/TTTT schools simply can't. People bemoan the third-tier private schools that cost 30k+ a year, but the fact that every private law school has raised tuition in lock-step seems indicative that something else is driving their upward price movements. I don't think they're dumb enough to collude on prices, but nonetheless you wouldn't expect that in a world where the lower-tiered schools have at least some incentive to provide quality at a lower price. I think a lot of that comes back to the resource requirements (or perceived requirements), having a full-time tenured faculty, having a library, having state-of-the-art technology, having a scholarly output, etc.

Don't get me wrong, tuition has also gone up because of unnaturally-high demand for the product, but you can't tell me that it really costs 30k+ to teach someone enough law to pass the bar and be a practicing lawyer, and you can't tell me that all third- and fourth-tier private schools independently decided to set their tuition higher and higher every year because not onl are they trying to meet USNWR's (unreachable, for most) 2nd-tier status, they're also trying to outpace ambiguous ABA requirements.

And those regulations won't change. The deans have no intention of ever seeing a "Motel 6" law school genuinely compete for national students. No businessman - and that's what these guys are at heart - gives up a monopoly.

It's a remarkably simple problem with a remarkably simple solution, but it's one you'll never see at a symposium like this, where they'd rather show concern for "social justice" while implicitly supporting a system that is blatantly socially unjust. Where is the justice in stifling honest competition and innovation? Where is the justice in having an exclusive system that saddles students with $150k+ in non-dischargable debt? Where is the justice in forcing people to sit through instruction that has absolutely no relevance to their professional career, merely because some professor is interested in English common law conversion actions?

Fair criticisms aside, capitalism is excellent at rewarding efficiency. If you admit your system is inefficient, as Dean Matasar did, the answer is to remove any artificial constraints. Don't misread me: I don't think there should be law schools on every corner. I can't imagine the U.S. needing more than 100-150 law schools for its present population.

But I'm not about to grandfather in a bunch of inefficient dinosaurs merely because they have a second-tier name. If someone can make a law school that teaches ethics, gives hands-on experience, teaches practical skills, and gets a 90% bar passage rate for Costco-level pricing , I'm all for it. Anyone who is seriously concerned about tuition costs should be as well.

That, I think, is ultimately what the future of legal education hinges on: whether the ABA changes its ways or someone makes the ABA change its ways. Beyond that, I doubt it will be much more than morally duplicitous talk by men in nice suits who acknowledge the problems but want to find a solution that's more amenable to their interests.

Very long and winding and barely-coherent, I'm sure, but that's my basic take.

Monday, February 28, 2011

UMass Law School "Proving Critics Wrong"

UMass Law School, not to be confused with the Massachusetts School of Law (or any of the other directional Massachusetts schools) is apparently turning into a cash cow for the good ol' Commonwealth:
With higher than expected enrollment, UMass School of Law, which operates as part of UMass Dartmouth, will turn over a lot more money this year to the state than the original projection of $674,000 in tuition revenue, officials said.

"It's subsidizing the taxpayer," UMD Chancellor Jean F. MacCormack said. "It's sending $918,000 to the commonwealth, and the commonwealth is not sending any money to it."
...
Officials had projected $5.9 million in total revenue for fiscal year 2011, but they have revised that number up to $6.9 million. Tuition is turned over to the state, while fees and private donations are used to operate the school.

Tuition at this thing is 23k for in-state students and 31k for out-of-state students.

Basically, the school accepted 36% more students than it anticipated and is apparently doing things on the cheap, which isn't entirely good, because, as one critic points out, they don't have the resources the ABA requires for accreditation, which they hope to achieve by 2017.

But my favorite line in the whole story is that last bit: tuition goes to the state, but fees and donations run the place. Isn't that screwy? Why are students expected to fund the state of Massachusetts while they're law school is floundering? And while I'm at it, wouldn't a real public university lower the costs and fees to the break even point in order to serve the public?

The real sad thing is that this place is pinning its hopes, more or less, on getting accredited six years from now. But that hasn't stopped it from selling the optimism:

Sandra Saenz, a second-year student who started when the school was still a private institution, said students are pleased with the transition so far.

"I really think everyone is very excited about this, especially the new students coming in," said Saenz, 36, who is from Seattle.

...

"I think there are many people familiar with the UMass name," she said. "It's going to be really nice to have that on my diploma."

Okay, so you're going to be 38, from Washington, and looking for an attorney job with a law school no one's heard of and you think it's going to be "really nice?" UMass is, what, the 5th or 6th nicest school in Massachusetts, and there's already an over-saturated legal market with at least three schools UMass Law doesn't have a prayer in outshining anytime soon. The only people impressed by UMass Law School are non-lawyers.

But hey, when you're desperate for good news, one year suffices to "prove critics wrong," I guess.

Friday, January 28, 2011

University of La Verne: A Different Kind of Misleading Advertising

The University of La Verne Law School (located in Ontario, California, and yes, I had to look it up, too) is trying again to bump it's "provisional" ABA accreditation to full ABA accreditation. The ABA's decision on their accreditation was delayed last year after only 34% of the graduating class passed the California bar exam on the first try. The school received provisional status in 2006 and the timeline is 5 years, so some are concerned that its time will expire and it won't be accredited, although it appears things are getting slightly better:
The exam pass rate for the same 2009 group rose to 73percent after students who had done poorly the first time retook the exam. These rates are called "ultimate" pass rates, which are also evaluated by the ABA. The 2010 first-time bar passage rate for graduating students at the law school reached 53percent.

Matt Jones, a first-year student at the law school, is among some first- and second-year students concerned about not being able to take the multi-state bar exam if they graduate at a school without ABA approval. Jones has nonetheless expressed satisfaction with the education he's receiving at the school, but he said the situation is a potential mess for many graduating with as much as $140,000 in debt.

This is a valid concern, isn't it? If you go to a school that's only provisionally accredited, you have one set of rights, but how many 0L's honestly realize that provisional accreditation expires? How many honestly realize that enrolling in a provisional school and graduating from a non-accredited school is a risk to take into account? Is the school upfront about this possible scenario?

Let's ask the Dean.

"They were told as graduates of provisional schools they're entitled to take the bar in all 50 states," [Dean Allen] Easley said. "The harder question is how much detail has gone into conversations with individuals about what would happen if the school loses its provisional status before they graduate. That gets to a level of detail you're not going to get into every single conversation. Certainly if anyone were to ask what were to happen if the school lost provisional approval before graduation, they would get an accurate answer. ... I don't think that question always gets asked."
Law school is a major investment of capital. The entire premise of our federal investment laws are that individuals should be fully apprised of the risks of an investment, especially the risks that have high acquisition costs (like trying to figure out the ABA's rules on accreditation).

And yet, this law school - a six-figure investment over three years - apparently only tells people "an accurate answer" of what would happen if they lose provisional status in the rare event that that person actually asks the question. Such a situation is blatantly contrary to the last 80 years of revelations about investment regulation, and it's also seemingly counter to common law contract principles (e.g., duty to disclose latent home defects).

Personally, I don't think the ABA should be accrediting schools where only ~50% of the class passes the bar exam, but that's just me. I just think the school has a duty to be entirely up front about their accreditation status, including the chance that they'll lose provisional accreditation.

But don't worry, kids, Dean Easley has a plan in case the ABA bucks a trend and actually rejects the school:

If a denial occurs, Easley said the law school would initiate an expedited application process to regain provisional status. He said recent precedent placed that process at about eight months.

"I think there's a good chance (for approval)," Easley said. "I believe we meet all the standards, but it's not my decision. The council is charged with making that decision. I hope we will get full approval and I believe we should."

Well, Dean Easley, you may meet the ABA's standards, but you don't meet mine, and you certainly weren't meeting your duty to prospective students if you weren't being entirely up front in disclosing that the school may lose accreditation.


Saturday, January 8, 2011

Massachusetts School of Law: Can You Love and Hate A Thing Simultaneously?

Michael Coyne is the Associate Dean at the regionally-accredited Massachusetts School of Law, although given the tone of his recent piece in the Worcester Telegram, he might be promoted to Minister of Propaganda.

It's hard to disagree with sentiments such as this:
  • Tuition costs at law schools accredited by the American Bar Association (ABA) have doubled in the last nine years....
  • Nowhere is the need for reform of higher education more obvious than in legal education....
  • The ABA continues its monopolistic control over access to legal education, imposing its costly outdated model of 19th century legal education on all ABA law schools, where annual tuitions have now reached $50,000, with $60,000 annual tuitions likely just three years away.
I love that there is, somewhere, someone operating a law school that is pissing off the ABA. I love that they do not use the LSAT and rely instead on personal interviews. I love that they try to keep tuition down (40% of other schools) while spitting out functional lawyers.

What I don't like are ridiculous statements like this:
Mortgages, bonds, and long-term loan forgiveness programs are now needed to pay for the cost of a law degree at an ABA law school.

With ever-escalating tuitions and access to loans dwindling, our country’s middle class finds itself hard-pressed to see the promise of opportunity that a law degree provides as nothing more than a mirage on an ever-elusive horizon.
Access is not really the issue. Virtually anyone has access to federally-backed loans to go to school. The problem is that the return on the investment is not high enough to justify the cost. In my experience, very few people have problems with "access to loans;" if anything, the problem is that loans are too freely given without concern for the loan being paid back. There's no need to rephrase this issue as one of class or access. It's bad enough that they lie about the return on investment to rake in more money.

And then there's this strain of junk:
The MSL model is a highly successful, practice-based, lower-cost method of legal education patterned after the medical school approach to higher education.
...
MSL is now nationally recognized for its effectiveness at training law students and its success in winning various regional and national advocacy awards. Legal journals are reporting on the growing number of ABA law school graduates vocal about having been forced to sacrifice their lives on the altar of high ABA law school tuitions.
Highly successful? Nationally recognized? Really? And why do complaining students show that your school makes any more sense than the rest of them? Again, the problem isn't restricted to tuition, it's a debt- and rate-of-return problem. MSL could cost $10 for a degree, but if the degree is only worth $5, it's just as much a scam as any other school, just on a smaller scale.

And then there's this whopper:
Americans have a God-given right to higher education. It is the promised path to a better future that every generation of Americans has passed on to those that followed. Let freedom and innovation ring. We will then be able to provide the “justice for all” that the inscription above our Supreme Court promises.
Um...yeah. The inscription is "Equal Justice For All," higher education is not a "promised path" to anything, and if we were really to "let freedom and innovation ring," the last remnants of professionalism in the attorney field would perish.

There's a bunch of phony rhetoric about how the LSAT discriminates against minorities and how law schools are too white, but to me the real problem in the article is that he misses the point.

That outdated model of 19th century education is not "costly" to run. On the contrary, it's quite cheap: pack 80 students in a room and get someone to talk about negligence or equitable servitude. The high costs seem to come from elsewhere, specifically the human resource department. Many law schools are still profit centers, and the fact that for-profit enterprises can compete with public schools and non-profit universities should give you a hint that the cost really isn't that prohibitive.

The problem isn't, either, that we've closed access. It's that demand for a legal education has risen dramatically on manipulated statistics, a distorted public perception, and federally-backed loans that are remarkably easy to get.

Remember the housing crisis? One of the factors of rapidly escalating home prices was the fact that we had this idea that there was a strong preference (bordering on a right) for everyone to own a home. Lender standards were relaxed so more minorities and other poor people would have more access to home ownership. Within a decade, people were defaulting like crazy - and it wasn't just those who purchased expensive, overpriced homes, but also those poor people who suddenly had access to 75k-100k homes. Message: you should not be "promising" or give a "right" to what are basically high-cost economic goods.

I swear this all just happened less than 5 years ago, but people like Michael Coyne seem to have missed the message. If the MSL's idea of fixing the law school problem is to admit all comers on lower tuition than the other guys with no regard as to the chances of paying it back, they're just as bad as everyone else. How do they think poor minorities come up with the 15k a year needed to pay tuition? Last time I checked, not many poor people have 45k in the bank and very, very few could pay that and their living expenses without incurring more debt. And when they graduate with 45k (or more) in unsecured, non-dischargable debt, how are they going to pay it back? Their school will not have a good reputation and they will have little chance at getting a mid- or large-firm job.

To my eyes, there are two things that need to fundamentally change with law schools; there are many minor changes, but many can be seen as tangents of these two:
  1. The curriculum needs to be changed to adequately prepare and develop modern working lawyers; this is an issue with the ABA's standards.
  2. The law schools must reduce the number of graduates and/or the cost of a legal education to accurately meet the demand for legal services; this is an issue with ABA accreditation, federal bankruptcy law, federal higher education lending standards, and plain old false advertising.
MSL seems to have figured out the first. But Mr. Coyne seems out to lunch regarding the second, and MSL's solution would only serve to saturate the legal marketplace ever more. There may be fewer students with 300k in debt under the current MSL model. But if lawyer work is only valued at 25k a year, is 75k in total law school debt even worth it? With completely-opened access to legal education, the market only becomes more saturated, and the earning power of every law degree - especially MSL'S pieces of paper - drops dramatically.

Grasp that, Michael Coyne, and you'll see why I can't embrace your school, even though I salute it's general attitude towards the ABA.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

How To Get A Law School Accredited, Part I

Last month, The Legal Dollar did a great post pointing out the apparent conflict of interest in the ABA's Standards Review and the law schools it regulates, as 11 out of 14 members of the committee are professors or deans.

With that in mind, I'd like to direct your attention to Binghamton University. Binghamton is looking for a new President. And although it sits in a state flush with law schools, Binghamton has officially stated its desire to open a law school as its next "logical step:"
With only two public law schools in New York State, at the University at Buffalo and CUNY-Queens, estimates show a law school at Binghamton would be in high demand, both by Binghamton University students and others.
...
In addition, standard economic projections indicate new expenditures would reach $10 million annually within five years, with an estimated annual impact of $26.4 million on the region and $33.7 on the state.
Why is this important now? Well, with BU's Presidency open, you'll just never guess who's on their shortlist:
He might not have taken the traditional path to a presidency, but that doesn't mean attorney Jonathan Alger shouldn't be Binghamton University's next leader, he told an audience Wednesday during a campus forum.
...
Perhaps the most direct question from a faculty member: "When would you start building a law school?"

Alger, who sits on the American Bar Association's Accreditation Committee, which oversees the accreditation of the nation's law schools, didn't give a date but said he could certainly help facilitate the conversation. The conversation, he said, wouldn't be easy.
Like heck it won't.

Alger currently serves as Senior Vice President and General Counsel at Rutgers, where he's been since 2004. Rutgers is not only the place involving the video taping suicide scandal from earlier this fall, but also is a Big East football school whose program has been caught in embezzlement scandals. I mention this because just last season Binghampton had a major scandal where six of its players were suddenly booted from the team (and its AD resigned) after the University's effort to spend its way to basketball glory went awry.

You would think they would be looking for someone to reshape their image after that debacle, and that a candidate who was compliance officer at a university during a financial scandal.

But, hey, Binghamton wants its law school, and we'll see if they elect this current ABA Accreditation Committee member the leader to do it. The fact that they're considering him in their top five speaks volumes to me.