Showing posts with label bar exam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bar exam. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

LaVerne Denied; Others At Risk? Not Really.

As has been widely reported, the ABA has formally denied LaVerne College of Law full accreditation citing its low bar passage rates. I've already written extensively on this topic and have noted that the many of the current students may suffer most, so I'll not regurgitate those feelings here. That said, I'm happy the ABA took a stand against a mediocre institution and only wish they would do it in areas other than bar passage (which, let's face it, can be taught with an intensive study course and can be gamed like any other standardized test), like actual attorney employment [x] months after graduation.

Now that the hammer has fallen on LaVerne, should anyone else be sweating?

According to this link, Thomas Jefferson, Whitter, Western State, and Southwestern were all at least 15% below the California State average in 2010. But all of them are already fully accredited, and they didn't do nearly as bad as LaVerne, so I don't expect any action here.

What about the nation's other four provisionally-accredited law schools? Well, none of them provide an easy out for the ABA.

The Charleston School of Law had a 72% bar pass rate last July, -4% against the overall, and -11% compared to the University of South Carolina. The previous exam was similar. Although there's no compelling reason to have more than one law school in South Carolina, they're in almost no danger on this front, and they're in the worst shape.

Drexel had an excellent year in 2009 and posted the state's best result in Feb. 2010. Elon has done well, and Charlotte isn't doing nearly as bad as LaVerne.

So unfortunately, I fear this will just be a one-time thing. The other new schools apparently have learned how to emphasize bar pass rates and teach to the test so that the ABA won't have a good reason to reject them. Not that being a graduate of Elon will be any easier for a prospective student than being a graduate from LaVerne, but I suppose one less school in the mix is a net positive.

EDIT: Looks like Charlotte and Elon both gained full accreditation (the title of the article reads "earned...") at the most recent vote despite graduates from either having little to no chance at meaningful legal employment. Way to go, ABA.

Friday, April 22, 2011

What's Up with the Virginia Bar Exam?

We all know that schools manipulate employment information because it's self-reported to the ABA and the rankings guru, but I wouldn't think a school could have any way of manipulating its bar exam passage rates. But then I saw this article today and I wondered if the wizards behind the curtain at Liberty had pulled it off:
Liberty University School of Law students achieved a 100 percent pass rate on the Virginia Bar Examination in February 2011.
...
Liberty is the only Virginia school to achieve the 100 percent rate in the state this year. Washington & Lee was at 90 percent; George Mason, 84.8 percent; University of Virginia, 75 percent; and the College of William & Mary, 73.3 percent.
I might actually believe the 100 percent claim with minimal skepticism if all the schools were above 90 percent. But with UVa and William and Mary at 75 and 73.3, I'm not sure I can buy it. I'm not an elitist by any stretch, but come on. Liberty is bottom-tier. The median LSAT in 2009 was a 150. 1L attrition in the Class of 2008 was 27.1%.

Liberty has in the past overstated its bar performance, but as far as I know there's no accounting metric that allows you to say student x passed they bar when they clearly failed. The official page says they hit 100%. Did only 5 students sit for it? The percentages look as though it may have been a low turnout.

In any event, it looks like the University of Virginia is taking measures to boost its pass rate (and claim it's doing something for unemployed graduates), but in the grand scheme of things, isn't this report - and others where third-tier toilets occasionally have higher pass rates than better-ranked schools - either an indictment of the bar exam process OR of the rankings system and prestige-based law?

The bar exam is either a good metric of competency or it isn't. If it is, the fact that lower-ranked schools can "do more with less" by taking 153 LSAT kids and getting them licensed while a school with 165 LSAT kids cannot get as many to pass signifies that the former institution is actually a become a competent lawyer. If it's not, then we should just scrap the thing and find a different way to certify people.

See also: http://www.ilrg.com/rankings/law/index.php/1/desc/Bar, where it shows in the 2009 data where you can see many lower-ranked schools outperforming higher ranked peers.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Elie Mystal Gives Terrible Advice

It's easy to pile on Elie Mystal, who must give nightmares for Harvard Law School's marketing department by being a public intellectual lightweight. But gosh darn it, it's kind of fun.

So today Elie - in contrast to his self-proclaimed skepticism about law school - has decided to tell a disgruntled 1L who wrote in that he should stay at his "elite" law school. What a shocker, eh?

Here's the kid's basic info:
  • At an unidentified "top 10" school
  • At the bottom of his class despite "working really hard"
  • Lost motivation and is pessimistic about his future in the law
  • No great pre-law work experience
  • Liberal arts major
  • "Significant financial help" from parents.
Now here are Elie's reasons for staying in law school:
(a) He picked the right parents.
(b) He got into the right school.
(c) He doesn’t have any other burning passion in his life.
(d) The worst part of law school is over.

Why wouldn’t this guy finish law school? Here is a situation where there is almost no downside. Assuming he’s going to be in a position to graduate debt-free or nearly debt-free, with a degree from an elite institution, what’s the harm? He can do anything he wants after it’s over. No, idiot law school marketers, not because you can do anything with a law degree. But because you can do anything with financially supportive parents.

This is retardation at work. Let's take these in order.

(a) "Rich parents" are not a valid reason to continue in law school. Elie claims that the kid is graduating "debt-free" if mom and dad pay for the whole thing. Furthermore, he claims that this guy can go to law school for "free."

That's an outright lie. Just because he's burning mom and dad's money instead of the federal government's doesn't mean that it's now "free." If anything, I'd feel guiltier about hoodwinking my parents into paying 50k a year instead of getting the government-banking complex to pay 50k a year. Furthermore, our concepts of "debt" and "free" should be broader than whether some 3rd-tier financial institution sends you a bill after graduation. The kid is sacrificing two more years of his life, plus taking the limitations of having a J.D. on his resume. Lost opportunities are a major downside, especially for someone in their early-to-mid 20s.

And if "you can do anything with financially supportive parents," that actually counsels against staying in law school doesn't it? Or it's a neutral at best? Your parents can help you start a business, travel the world, pursue other passions. There's plenty of investment alternatives here, so even with rich parents, you have to defeat the alternatives and prove law is a strong enough investment to keep that capital invested in it.

(b) There's no such thing as the "right school" for someone who finishes at the bottom of the class. Elie the elitist called it a "top 10" school, so I'm guessing it's somewhere like Penn or Northwestern or NYU and not Harvard or Yale. Given the continuing BigLaw and government cut-backs, I would not gamble on being a bottom-quartile graduate at Northwestern or Penn. Georgetown has already been caught fudging its graduate employment numbers, and Duke had to set up a program to ensure all its graduates landed jobs.

Never mind that to be an attorney, one actually has to pass the bar exam. Depending on what "bottom of the class" means to this kid, he might find the bar exam a very difficult challenge. For example, according to Law School Numbers, at NYU 6% of bar takers don't pass on the first try. For Michigan, 8% of in-state bar exam takers did not pass in 2007. For Cal-Berkeley, 6-16% fail the"notoriously hard" California bar exam the first time around.

I can guarantee you some of this kid's classmates didn't work that hard at all. If he put in a top effort and wound up near the bottom, he's probably going to have a difficult time with the bar. At which point in time, his "top school" doesn't matter at all. Investing all that time only to find the bar exam an insurmountable hurdle (like >2% of the class often does, even from "elite" schools) is a major downside; you cannot ignore this possibility.

So the bottom line is that even at a top school, this kid needs to have the right attitude to be paying the not-so-free full sticker price.

(c) The question is not whether he has some other burning passion, it's whether he actually has a burning passion for the law. This person seems very pessimistic and burnt out. He has no motivation by his own words. If he has no motivation at the end of 1L (before spring exams, when he might have a chance to redeem his fall performance), how is he going to feel answering interrogatories at 9 pm? How is he going to do well in the next two years? How is he going to have to drive to do top work for his clients and/or his firm? How is he going to be gung-ho about finding work opportunities in his 2L and 3L years?

This student seems to have gone to law school because he had nothing better to do. That's not a good reason to stay in law school when he has no strong desire to actually practice law.

(d) The worst part of law school is not necessarily over. People like to talk up 1L year like it's some sort of boot camp, but at least in my experience, parts of 2L are worse depending on your array of classes. And at least during 1L year, any thoughts of unemployment and debt repayment are far in the distance. Try talking to a generic 3L right now and the fog of unemployment and taking the bar exam plagues them worse than even 1L exams. 1L is time-consuming and stressful, but it's a time-limited stress; once mid-May hits there's no more 1L Socratic method or harsh-curve exams. That doesn't work with debt default.

All in all, this person needs to think long and hard about the law, and if they have no honest drive to be a lawyer, they need to get out after this semester. The connections are, for the most part, already made. With "financially supportive" parents, the life reorganization won't be that bad, and new experiences can quickly wipe away the tarnish of a bad year in law school.

The loss of time and money is a major harm, Elie. To spend significant amounts of both, the student should have a positive, compelling reason for staying in law school. This student does not.

Would you personally spend $100,000 and two years of your life on something you had no enthusiasm for that had no guarantee of paying any kind of a reward down the road? Of course not, and if this didn't involve an "elite" law school, I can't believe even Elie Mystal would be so dumb as to suggest otherwise.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Joseph Rakofsky: Both an Idiot and a Symptom

This entry was corrected for possible minor errors due to possible discrepancies I learned of during the week of May 16. A summary of the minor changes can be seen here.

Others have already commented on the Joseph Rakofsky story, but in reading commentary on the issue, I'm a bit bothered by how many people want to call him a moron and move on as if that's the end of the inquiry.

To refresh everyone's memory, Rakofsky, a 2009 Touro grad with very little actual experience, and a law license in New Jersey, decided to try a murder case in Washington, D.C. As one might expect, it did not go well, and multiple people, including the judge and the Washington Post courthouse reporter, found Rakofsky's performance a sign of "incompetence." I trust their judgment.

Is Joseph Rakofsky an idiot? Absolutely. Let us count the ways.

But he's also a symptom of one of the fundamental problems of attorney oversupply. Back in December, I pointed out that having a large mass of desperate unemployed attorneys can put ethical obligations into jeopardy in the context of foreclosure mills. There, attorneys looking for a job - any job - would have an incentive to sacrifice morals to bring in a paycheck.

Rakofsky is the Horatio Alger, "pull himself up by his bootstraps," side of that same coin.

Rokofsky's website is now down, but here is his "About Me" paragraph that I rescued from google cache:
Mr. Rakofsky has worked on cases involving Murder, Embezzlement, Tax Evasion, Civil RICO, Securities Fraud, Bank Fraud, Insurance Fraud, Wire Fraud, Conspiracy, Money Laundering, Drug Trafficking, Grand Larceny, Identity Theft, Counterfeit Credit Card Enterprise and Aggravated Harassment. Following graduation from law school, he worked for one of the biggest civil litigation firms on the east coast and has worked for boutique white-collar criminal defense firms in Manhattan. During law school, Mr. Rakofsky interned at the Legal Aid Society (in Suffolk County). Prior to studying law, Mr. Rakofsky studied Economics and interviewed at a well-respected investment bank with branches all over the world. Prior to law school, Mr. Rakofsky earned a Bachelor of Science in Biology, concentrating his attention on DNA.
Hey, my attention was concentrated on DNA too, specifically the kind at Tri-Delt. But I digress again.

It's clear that Rakofsky's bio is milking every minor experience he's ever had especially since he just graduated in 2009. Filed a service return for a credit card collection? Sounds like identity theft experience to me! But this is the monster we've created. The options for attorneys who can't find real jobs out of law schools are either to try something else, settle for doc review-type jobs, or set out on their own. Commentators often promote the idea of setting up shop as a viable alternative to getting a job, and many law school deans (Thomas Mengler, as one example) justify purposefully flooding the market by claiming that more solos and firms means lower prices and better lawyering (a really stupid conclusion, but that's for another day).

Well, here we have a kid who clearly wanted to do criminal law. He set up a slick website (financialcrimelaw.com; great url!) to make him look like the smooth legal hucksters on TV. He set up four offices. To account for his relative virginity, he listed every conceivable experience he could. Such is necessary to compete with the 40+ crowd who market their prematurely-gray hair like a badge of honor rather than a sign of stress.

Isn't this exactly what the Menglers of the world want him to do? Even if it isn't, is this not the natural result when you saddle kids with $100k+ in debt and pigeonhole them into an overcrowded field? Aren't they going to set up sleek websites and offer discounts and hope and pray that they make it through their first cases without looking like a doofus? After all ,can't have a gap on the resume. Must be working, getting out there, networking with other solos, gaining experience. Prior to last week, most industry apologists would have likely held up Rakofsky as an example of what unemployed law graduates should be doing, that they should be entrepreneurial.

But entrepreneurship is not good when the product being peddled is an inferior quality and public welfare is placed at risk. Rakofsky may not have even been aware that he was peddling an inferior product; he probably honestly believed he was competent, and such is part of the problem with a "Wild West" view of licensing, accrediting, and more or less forcing some graduates to solo it.

Everybody lost except the people at Touro who cashed his tuition checks. Everybody.

In medicine, graduates of medical school are not allowed to just "hang a shingle" and set up their own practices. They must go through a 3-5 year period called residency where they learn to actually practice medicine on real people in real hospitals. You are not allowed to become board certified and practice medicine without supervision until you have completed a residency program. All graduates of medical school programs are more or less guaranteed a space in a residency program because the medical profession actually cares about integrity and welfare and limits the output of medical schools. They made a sound policy decision to be cautious and prevent unprepared doctors from being unleashed on the public.

I hold no illusion that law is as important as medicine, but I completely fail to see how anyone in their right mind can continue to license attorneys to do things that they are entirely unqualified to do. Why is there not a residency requirement, or the equivalent? Changing law school to be two years of study and two-three years of low-paid study under a practicing attorney doesn't seem to be too big of a burden. Neither does requiring specialization or making the bar exam more practical to the actual day-to-day practice of law in a specific jurisdiction.

The system is completely broken. It cannot filter out people like Rakofsky; instead it allows them to flow through by the thousands and onto an unsuspecting marketplace. It has no training safeguards to ensure that people handling murder cases can actually handle murder cases. The more hubris-filled unemployed attorneys will do exactly what Rakofsky did; his story made the rounds, others' do not. But he is by no means unique. He is exactly what happens when you license type A personalities to do things before they've actually shown they can do it.

We do not license people to drive classes of vehicles they have never touched before. We do not license surgeons who have never held a scalpel. Yet in many cases attorneys can handle matters they know little about merely because they've duped some poor client into believing they're "the guy."

A real profession doesn't let that situation develop, and it stops the nonsense once it becomes apparent.

Friday, November 19, 2010

BAR/BRI Looking to be Sold - Why?

Yesterday I heard a rumor from some colleagues who actually paid into the Bar/Bri scheme that they received an e-mail that Thomson-Reuters put Bar/Bri on the sale block. I wanted to post, but wasn't able to find an article or press release to source. Now AbovetheLaw has gone ahead and reported on it, complete with a connection to T-R's acquisition of Indian outsourcing company Pangea3 and the full letter sent to Bar/Bri's subscribers.
This decision to sell is in no way related to BARBRI’s performance. BARBRI is the leading bar review course in the United States with over 40 years of experience, strong leadership and quality of service. Our parent company believes, however, that bar preparation no longer fits its long-term strategic vision, which is to provide intelligent information and workflow solutions to professionals.
As disclosure, I want to note that I think Bar/Bri is a leach that does a disservice to the legal field. I have little regard for its business and believe that its continual existence is evidence that the bar associations are not doing their job to the best of their abilities (e.g. that the bar exam doesn't test the skills it should). But that's an entry for another day.

To be fair to all parties, Bar/Bri is something of a misfit in Thomson-Reuters. Its existence there is an accident of corporate history. Bar/Bri first merged into Harcourt and then into Thomson-West publishing. This made sense because Thomson-West was the largest legal publisher in the country, providing a broad range of legal information. Acquiring a small, profitable company who published legal books designed to aid bar passage made sense. Furthermore, Thomson Corporation (the parent company of Thomson-West) was one of the world's leading textbook publishers and had an expansive business in standardized testing (through Prometric). So Bar/Bri fit in multiple ways in Thomson-West's overall scheme.

Fast forward to the 2000s. Research of all stripes is moving rapidly online. Thomson Corporation begins acquiring all sorts of online information distillers across a wide range of industries. In 2006, Kenneth Thomson dies and is replaced by son David Thomson. In 2007, Thomson sells its entire textbook publication and standardized testing division, leaving Bar/Bri as an outlier saved only by the fact that it's grouped with West ("Thomson Legal") and not Thomson Learning. In 2008, Thomson acquires Reuters, the 2nd largest news dissemination service in the world. The resulting company was a $30 billion behemoth whose interests is in professional news distribution. Westlaw fits in this mold; comparatively-small Bar/Bri does not. Consequently, from their perspective, it makes sense to sell Bar/Bri as an outlier to their current business interests.

But why NOW? And why announce it publicly?

Even if a company is a misfit, a corporate conglomerate isn't going to sell it unless it's a good time to sell; to do otherwise would be a disservice to shareholders. Furthermore, leaking it to the world that a sale is happening guarantees that no one's going to overpay for it.

It is true that Bar/Bri has increased competition, but they're still the king of Bar preparation services with a rather large moat. Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but my guess is that Thomson-Reuters looks at this being the best time to sell Bar/Bri because they don't see much revenue growth in the business. Even with new law schools being accredited every day, they don't see Bar/Bri being a worthwhile investment to hang on to, when it's the default choice for Bar preparation?

Is there a chance that Thomson-Reuters sees what's going on in the law school world and realizes we may be reaching the end of the line with lawyer saturation? The people at T-R aren't dumb. The reason they're still around in a post-newspaper, post-print world is that they were forerunners in online information. Things like Westlaw and a plethora of science, financial, and healthcare tools.

Anytime anyone with that kind of vision to see where the world was going in 5-10 years does something like offload a subsidiary that by all accounts is profitable and the leading bar review preparation course, one should ask a simple question: what do they see the market looking like in 5-10 years?

Since they apparently don't see the market for Bar/Bri's services being as strong in 5-10 years (or as relatively strong) as they see it now, at least enough to keep it within their legal services family, why might that be? And why would they be so desperate to unload it that they don't care that Bar/Bri went public with the information? What do they know that the people supporting law school don't?