Showing posts with label Above the Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Above the Law. Show all posts

Thursday, April 14, 2011

Elie Mystal Gives Terrible Advice

It's easy to pile on Elie Mystal, who must give nightmares for Harvard Law School's marketing department by being a public intellectual lightweight. But gosh darn it, it's kind of fun.

So today Elie - in contrast to his self-proclaimed skepticism about law school - has decided to tell a disgruntled 1L who wrote in that he should stay at his "elite" law school. What a shocker, eh?

Here's the kid's basic info:
  • At an unidentified "top 10" school
  • At the bottom of his class despite "working really hard"
  • Lost motivation and is pessimistic about his future in the law
  • No great pre-law work experience
  • Liberal arts major
  • "Significant financial help" from parents.
Now here are Elie's reasons for staying in law school:
(a) He picked the right parents.
(b) He got into the right school.
(c) He doesn’t have any other burning passion in his life.
(d) The worst part of law school is over.

Why wouldn’t this guy finish law school? Here is a situation where there is almost no downside. Assuming he’s going to be in a position to graduate debt-free or nearly debt-free, with a degree from an elite institution, what’s the harm? He can do anything he wants after it’s over. No, idiot law school marketers, not because you can do anything with a law degree. But because you can do anything with financially supportive parents.

This is retardation at work. Let's take these in order.

(a) "Rich parents" are not a valid reason to continue in law school. Elie claims that the kid is graduating "debt-free" if mom and dad pay for the whole thing. Furthermore, he claims that this guy can go to law school for "free."

That's an outright lie. Just because he's burning mom and dad's money instead of the federal government's doesn't mean that it's now "free." If anything, I'd feel guiltier about hoodwinking my parents into paying 50k a year instead of getting the government-banking complex to pay 50k a year. Furthermore, our concepts of "debt" and "free" should be broader than whether some 3rd-tier financial institution sends you a bill after graduation. The kid is sacrificing two more years of his life, plus taking the limitations of having a J.D. on his resume. Lost opportunities are a major downside, especially for someone in their early-to-mid 20s.

And if "you can do anything with financially supportive parents," that actually counsels against staying in law school doesn't it? Or it's a neutral at best? Your parents can help you start a business, travel the world, pursue other passions. There's plenty of investment alternatives here, so even with rich parents, you have to defeat the alternatives and prove law is a strong enough investment to keep that capital invested in it.

(b) There's no such thing as the "right school" for someone who finishes at the bottom of the class. Elie the elitist called it a "top 10" school, so I'm guessing it's somewhere like Penn or Northwestern or NYU and not Harvard or Yale. Given the continuing BigLaw and government cut-backs, I would not gamble on being a bottom-quartile graduate at Northwestern or Penn. Georgetown has already been caught fudging its graduate employment numbers, and Duke had to set up a program to ensure all its graduates landed jobs.

Never mind that to be an attorney, one actually has to pass the bar exam. Depending on what "bottom of the class" means to this kid, he might find the bar exam a very difficult challenge. For example, according to Law School Numbers, at NYU 6% of bar takers don't pass on the first try. For Michigan, 8% of in-state bar exam takers did not pass in 2007. For Cal-Berkeley, 6-16% fail the"notoriously hard" California bar exam the first time around.

I can guarantee you some of this kid's classmates didn't work that hard at all. If he put in a top effort and wound up near the bottom, he's probably going to have a difficult time with the bar. At which point in time, his "top school" doesn't matter at all. Investing all that time only to find the bar exam an insurmountable hurdle (like >2% of the class often does, even from "elite" schools) is a major downside; you cannot ignore this possibility.

So the bottom line is that even at a top school, this kid needs to have the right attitude to be paying the not-so-free full sticker price.

(c) The question is not whether he has some other burning passion, it's whether he actually has a burning passion for the law. This person seems very pessimistic and burnt out. He has no motivation by his own words. If he has no motivation at the end of 1L (before spring exams, when he might have a chance to redeem his fall performance), how is he going to feel answering interrogatories at 9 pm? How is he going to do well in the next two years? How is he going to have to drive to do top work for his clients and/or his firm? How is he going to be gung-ho about finding work opportunities in his 2L and 3L years?

This student seems to have gone to law school because he had nothing better to do. That's not a good reason to stay in law school when he has no strong desire to actually practice law.

(d) The worst part of law school is not necessarily over. People like to talk up 1L year like it's some sort of boot camp, but at least in my experience, parts of 2L are worse depending on your array of classes. And at least during 1L year, any thoughts of unemployment and debt repayment are far in the distance. Try talking to a generic 3L right now and the fog of unemployment and taking the bar exam plagues them worse than even 1L exams. 1L is time-consuming and stressful, but it's a time-limited stress; once mid-May hits there's no more 1L Socratic method or harsh-curve exams. That doesn't work with debt default.

All in all, this person needs to think long and hard about the law, and if they have no honest drive to be a lawyer, they need to get out after this semester. The connections are, for the most part, already made. With "financially supportive" parents, the life reorganization won't be that bad, and new experiences can quickly wipe away the tarnish of a bad year in law school.

The loss of time and money is a major harm, Elie. To spend significant amounts of both, the student should have a positive, compelling reason for staying in law school. This student does not.

Would you personally spend $100,000 and two years of your life on something you had no enthusiasm for that had no guarantee of paying any kind of a reward down the road? Of course not, and if this didn't involve an "elite" law school, I can't believe even Elie Mystal would be so dumb as to suggest otherwise.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Yale Applications Down; William Mitchell Goes Transparent

As Above the Law reports today, Yale applications are down nearly 16.5% this year. Naturally, this doesn't quite make sense to Elie Mystal:
The NYT says “stay away from law school,” and applications to Yale drop. But if you read Above the Law, you pick up nuances like “stay away from crappy law schools.” See how much more subtle and informative that is? I know, I know, it bothers me too when the print media sensationalizes things.
No, Elie, you elitist T-14 marketing shill, the point is that it's so bad that even going to awesome schools may be a losing proposition. See, for example, you! People who went to T-14 schools, did well, scored at BigLaw, and were spit out 3-5 years later are a dime a dozen. In a world where even Georgetown has to fudge numbers, you know something's up with the game itself.

But Elie found a "more plausible" reason why there was a catacylsmic drop: Yale decided to start requiring a "dean's certificate" from one's former school:
Ah, now that’s an explanation that comports with what I’ve come to know about prospective law students. For many of them, it’s their first important professional decision; why would they put in the extra work required to apply to the very best law school? Paperwork? Bah. “I don’t want to do no paperwork, I want to be a lawyer.”

Look, I know it seems like I want there to be fewer law students by any means necessary. But really I just want people to be making intelligent decisions.

Not applying to Yale just because it requires more paperwork is not smart. But I suppose the kids not applying to Yale for that reason weren’t going to be Yale Law School material anyway.

Does this idiot honestly believe that otherwise-serious applicants strayed from a tip-top law school because they had to a dean's certificate, something that some other law schools already require, if I'm not mistaken? Seriously?

I know this might be a shock to people like Elie, but it wasn't just the 155 LSATs who are affected by the legal profession's down-turn. Those with 175 LSATs and shiny credentials are less likely to go as well if they understand it (properly) to be a giant crapshoot. If anything, the B.A. holder with the 170+ LSAT is more likely to be able to score a lucrative job absent law school than the 155 LSAT holder. Thus, Yale's prospective applicant pool might drop, as the 165 LSAT kids may not think themselves good enough to even bother.

It's all about alternatives. The kid who can get into Yale often has many of them, meaning there's no reason to take the (increasingly-higher) risk that law will not pan out. Kids lower on the academic totem pole may not have those alternatives and may keep applying to solid schools hoping they can secure a job down the line. Above all else, it's downright stupid to assume that high-achievers are not applying to a top law school because it involved an extra step when the LSAC process is already a bunch of hoop-jumping and the high achievers are more likely to jump through hoops, anyway. How condescending, yet entirely unsurprising.

Elie would, I suppose, rather propagate his elitist worldview that there's something magical about Yale ("Yale Law School material," blech) and the other top schools that somehow immunizes them from a lack of interest in law school unless students are being lazy and irrational.

___________________________________________

In happier news, William Mitchell has decided to be more transparent and has published a wide array of helpful information of its website to better diagnose the school and its propensity for producing quality graduates. Check this out:
  • 67% of reporting employed 2009 graduates hold a position where bar admission is required.
  • Overall average salaries range between $39,000 and $75,000, although there was a steep decline in the number of 2009 graduates reporting information.
  • The 2009 overall average of $58,687 for 176 people includes at least 15 salaries of $100k or more.
  • 11 graduates are working in publishing (Westlaw is in Minneapolis, if I'm not mistaken)
  • 21 are in "solo practice," a dramatic rise from the '06-'07 numbers.
I still think there's some creative accounting going on here (they get 93% employed by discounting people who went back to school and are not seeking work, which to me presents a chicken-egg problem), but overall it's wonderful to have more informative numbers about what is going on.

Clearly, they're still oversaturating the area if only 2/3 of their employed graduates actually need a J.D. The salary information seems far more reasonable, even if it's still on the high side for 50-70% of graduates. I also find it curious that they used to focus on medians and now they're doing averages (I wonder which one is higher...).

The bottom line is that there's no way in heck I pay 50k a year plus interest to have a chance at a job averaging 58k with all sorts of strings attached.

Hopefully more schools will put out detailed information like this, even if it's buried deep on their side. I'll snoop around and see if I can find some others, and I encourage readers to email me if they spot any that I can dissect here.

Friday, March 18, 2011

Virginia Law Weekley's Dan Gocek on Above the Law

Dan Gocek at Virginia Law Weekly has an interesting rant on Above the Law:
What I dislike about Above the Law is its penchant for encouraging distaste and resentment between various groups of people, such as students from different schools or those with jobs and those without. This can be seen in posts such as their “Douchiest Law School” competition, in which students presumably with very little knowledge of schools other than their own vote on which law school they think is the “douchiest.”
...
[A] large percentage of the posts on Above the Law displaying this sort of ignorant obnoxiousness seem to be penned by Mr. Mystal, who, in another post, claims that he and his wife’s combined salary of nearly $250,000 does not provide him with enough money to buy a decent computer. Although I’m normally not very sympathetic to those who complain about money troubles while simultaneously admitting to living “as far above their means as possible”, the idea that Mr. Mystal doesn’t have a 42” Mac desktop on which to write this fecal matter posing as language really brings a tear to my eye.
Encourage you to go and read the whole thing. Great stuff. I don't really disagree with it, and I don't really have much to add.