Showing posts with label law school costs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label law school costs. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

The Waste of Legal Scholarship

This shouldn't surprise anyone, but Richard Neumann of Hofstra has pointed out that legal "scholarship" costs almost $100,000 per article by a full-tenured professor during a recent educational conference on tenure and the future of legal education:
Even articles written by assistant professors at lower-paying law schools come with a price tag between $25,000 and $42,000, he estimated.

Neumann also pointed to research suggesting that 43% of law review articles are never cited by anyone. "At least a third of these things have no value," he said. "Who is paying for that? Students who will graduate with six figures of debt."
Neumann actually uses this as a reason to argue for protecting tenure; he seems to believe that the tenure protection will allow faculty to think creatively about revamping legal education. I think he's a bit biased by his stake in the fight, but no one's perfect, and his realization that student's increasing debt loads are caused in some small part by subsidizing worthless research is a good start.

Also on the panel were Dean Yellen of Loyola-Chicago and Dean Matasar of NYLS. It seems like these guys do nothing but travel to conferences and pontificate. I wonder if Neumann will ever talk about the wasted money paying deans to fly around the country. There's nothing really unexpected from either.

Those unread articles in law journals cost tens of thousands to produce with very low benefits (as in, more people will read this sentence than who honestly read most secondary journals). Under no cost-benefit analysis would these things ever get greenlighted, but unfortunately, American universities not only eschewed cost-benefit analysis, but most made production of this worthless crud the hallmark of a tenure-worthy professor (instead of, say, teaching). Instead of producing only truly meritorious scholarship, the academy (including its legal peers) took to publishing as a CV-stuffer and convinced itself that its "scholarly mission" requires constant publication regardless of the quality. Their work becomes important because they produced it, not because it shares any qualities with truly important work.

And the students are left shouldering the cost of these things, all so the university can feel better about itself under standards and "missions" it fully made up.

I'm not saying all scholarship is worthless, not even all legal scholarship; that would be absurd. But the system we have now is a crap machine that has allows people to be employed at lucrative salaries for writing things no one wants. For the time, effort, and energy spent on articles that have no economic value, all to impress some students on a law review board, these individuals could be doing things that have some value to society, like running clinics to represent indigent clients. At the very least, it's unjust to have students subsidize these quixotic efforts, just as it would be to force students to subsidize novel or screenplay or poetry anthology attempts.

$100,000 with a good chance it never proves worthy enough to cite. If you think of all the alternative uses for that $100,000 per full-time professor article and you write out all the possible options, your list is guaranteed to be far more interesting than 95% of what's come out of legal academia in the last few decades. And it will probably contain some items the paying customers would actually use and appreciate.

Saturday, January 8, 2011

Massachusetts School of Law: Can You Love and Hate A Thing Simultaneously?

Michael Coyne is the Associate Dean at the regionally-accredited Massachusetts School of Law, although given the tone of his recent piece in the Worcester Telegram, he might be promoted to Minister of Propaganda.

It's hard to disagree with sentiments such as this:
  • Tuition costs at law schools accredited by the American Bar Association (ABA) have doubled in the last nine years....
  • Nowhere is the need for reform of higher education more obvious than in legal education....
  • The ABA continues its monopolistic control over access to legal education, imposing its costly outdated model of 19th century legal education on all ABA law schools, where annual tuitions have now reached $50,000, with $60,000 annual tuitions likely just three years away.
I love that there is, somewhere, someone operating a law school that is pissing off the ABA. I love that they do not use the LSAT and rely instead on personal interviews. I love that they try to keep tuition down (40% of other schools) while spitting out functional lawyers.

What I don't like are ridiculous statements like this:
Mortgages, bonds, and long-term loan forgiveness programs are now needed to pay for the cost of a law degree at an ABA law school.

With ever-escalating tuitions and access to loans dwindling, our country’s middle class finds itself hard-pressed to see the promise of opportunity that a law degree provides as nothing more than a mirage on an ever-elusive horizon.
Access is not really the issue. Virtually anyone has access to federally-backed loans to go to school. The problem is that the return on the investment is not high enough to justify the cost. In my experience, very few people have problems with "access to loans;" if anything, the problem is that loans are too freely given without concern for the loan being paid back. There's no need to rephrase this issue as one of class or access. It's bad enough that they lie about the return on investment to rake in more money.

And then there's this strain of junk:
The MSL model is a highly successful, practice-based, lower-cost method of legal education patterned after the medical school approach to higher education.
...
MSL is now nationally recognized for its effectiveness at training law students and its success in winning various regional and national advocacy awards. Legal journals are reporting on the growing number of ABA law school graduates vocal about having been forced to sacrifice their lives on the altar of high ABA law school tuitions.
Highly successful? Nationally recognized? Really? And why do complaining students show that your school makes any more sense than the rest of them? Again, the problem isn't restricted to tuition, it's a debt- and rate-of-return problem. MSL could cost $10 for a degree, but if the degree is only worth $5, it's just as much a scam as any other school, just on a smaller scale.

And then there's this whopper:
Americans have a God-given right to higher education. It is the promised path to a better future that every generation of Americans has passed on to those that followed. Let freedom and innovation ring. We will then be able to provide the “justice for all” that the inscription above our Supreme Court promises.
Um...yeah. The inscription is "Equal Justice For All," higher education is not a "promised path" to anything, and if we were really to "let freedom and innovation ring," the last remnants of professionalism in the attorney field would perish.

There's a bunch of phony rhetoric about how the LSAT discriminates against minorities and how law schools are too white, but to me the real problem in the article is that he misses the point.

That outdated model of 19th century education is not "costly" to run. On the contrary, it's quite cheap: pack 80 students in a room and get someone to talk about negligence or equitable servitude. The high costs seem to come from elsewhere, specifically the human resource department. Many law schools are still profit centers, and the fact that for-profit enterprises can compete with public schools and non-profit universities should give you a hint that the cost really isn't that prohibitive.

The problem isn't, either, that we've closed access. It's that demand for a legal education has risen dramatically on manipulated statistics, a distorted public perception, and federally-backed loans that are remarkably easy to get.

Remember the housing crisis? One of the factors of rapidly escalating home prices was the fact that we had this idea that there was a strong preference (bordering on a right) for everyone to own a home. Lender standards were relaxed so more minorities and other poor people would have more access to home ownership. Within a decade, people were defaulting like crazy - and it wasn't just those who purchased expensive, overpriced homes, but also those poor people who suddenly had access to 75k-100k homes. Message: you should not be "promising" or give a "right" to what are basically high-cost economic goods.

I swear this all just happened less than 5 years ago, but people like Michael Coyne seem to have missed the message. If the MSL's idea of fixing the law school problem is to admit all comers on lower tuition than the other guys with no regard as to the chances of paying it back, they're just as bad as everyone else. How do they think poor minorities come up with the 15k a year needed to pay tuition? Last time I checked, not many poor people have 45k in the bank and very, very few could pay that and their living expenses without incurring more debt. And when they graduate with 45k (or more) in unsecured, non-dischargable debt, how are they going to pay it back? Their school will not have a good reputation and they will have little chance at getting a mid- or large-firm job.

To my eyes, there are two things that need to fundamentally change with law schools; there are many minor changes, but many can be seen as tangents of these two:
  1. The curriculum needs to be changed to adequately prepare and develop modern working lawyers; this is an issue with the ABA's standards.
  2. The law schools must reduce the number of graduates and/or the cost of a legal education to accurately meet the demand for legal services; this is an issue with ABA accreditation, federal bankruptcy law, federal higher education lending standards, and plain old false advertising.
MSL seems to have figured out the first. But Mr. Coyne seems out to lunch regarding the second, and MSL's solution would only serve to saturate the legal marketplace ever more. There may be fewer students with 300k in debt under the current MSL model. But if lawyer work is only valued at 25k a year, is 75k in total law school debt even worth it? With completely-opened access to legal education, the market only becomes more saturated, and the earning power of every law degree - especially MSL'S pieces of paper - drops dramatically.

Grasp that, Michael Coyne, and you'll see why I can't embrace your school, even though I salute it's general attitude towards the ABA.