Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fraud. Show all posts

Saturday, May 28, 2011

Thoughts on the Thomas Jefferson Law School Class Action

As many of you likely know, Thomas Jefferson College of Law, brand new campus and all, has been sued in a class action lawsuit:

According to the complaint, plaintiff Anna Alaburda graduated with honors from the San Diego law school in 2008 and passed the California bar examination, but has been unable to secure full-time employment as an attorney. She sent more than 150 resumes to law firms and received only one job offer that was "less favorable than non-law related jobs that were available to her."

...

She accrued more than $150,000 in student loans during her law school years, the complaint says.
...

Beth Kransberger, associate dean for student affairs at Thomas Jefferson, said that the school does not misrepresent its employment statistics.

"The school has always followed the guidelines established by the ABA. We've always been accurate in what we report, and we've always followed the system given to us by the ABA," Kransberger said. "This lawsuit is very much about a larger debate. This is part of the debate about whether it's practical to pursue a graduate degree in these difficult economic times."

Others have already covered this fairly well (see First Tier Toilet, PresTTTigious, and SubprimeJD) and I have skimmed the complaint and I don't wish to go on a point-by-point review of the merits, suffice to say that: (a) I'm happy that someone finally did this; and (b) it will be very interesting to see if the fraud claims can get past a motion for summary judgment. My opinion, devoid of any knowledge of California law and not exactly experienced in fraud, is that there are a few hurdles that might prove tricky to clear (e.g., reasonable reliance). It will also be very interesting to see if the USNWR or the ABA become involved somehow.

But I would like to point out a few things from the National Law Journal's write-up.

First, this student attended TJLS from 2005-2008, when the cost of attendance was around 43k (LSN currently lists the 2006-2007 number at $42,948). Her $150,000 in debt may seem obscene, but consider that in the 3-6 years since she's been in law school, tuition alone has risen to over 40k per year. The TJLS website does not list a total cost of attendance with this figure, but it has to be around 60k. As bad as the complaint looks with respect to Ms. Alaburda, students entering in the fall of 2011 are going to significantly worse off.

Second, Beth Kransberger is.... well, wrong. That's about the nicest way I can put it.

As far as I know, compliance with standards established by one's own industry almost never can completely relieve an industry participant of liability when they're dealing with an outside party; at an absolute minimum, it shouldn't. For example, if every participant in the automotive industry uses the same style of brake pads because the brake pads are endorsed by the safety committee of the industry's trade association, the automotive manufacturers may (and should) still be possibly liable in tort for brake pad failures. Why? Because it's possible that the entire industry has the standards wrong, for whatever reason.

Another example of this is in accounting and securities fraud. If I'm not mistaken, a company can comply 100% with standards set by FASB in its financial reports and still be liable for misrepresentation under various fraud provisions. Compliance with the existing standard is positive evidence for the company, but it's not dispositive because the standard itself may not completely align with the other area of law (here, fraud).

There's no perfect alignment between the ABA's reporting metrics and the California fraud statutes, and I doubt that the California legislature has ever endorsed compliance with ABA rules as a safe harbor against fraud claims. Fraud ultimately isn't about forcing companies to comply with their own industry's practices. It's about forcing companies to be honest with the public at large. So TJLS' compliance with the ABA's guidelines should have very little to do with whether their admissions presentations were deceptive to the average consumer.

Furthermore, this idea that this action is merely part of a "debate about whether it's practical to pursue a graduate degree in these difficult economic times" is laughable. This has nothing to do with "difficult economic times" and nothing do with general graduate degrees.

Am I skeptical of graduate school - and higher education - in general? Yes. But not all graduate degrees are cut from the same cloth. Medical school and dental school live by their own rules. Liberal arts PhD programs often have an intrinsic, non-economic value, and the market in those areas has been tight dating back decades (and has relatively little to do with the economic cycle). Advanced degrees in the sciences and engineering are more dependent on the economic cycle, but are generally still in demand (or so people say).

What is spelled out in this complaint is unique to law and exists independently of the economic cycle. Indeed, the complaint itself mentions that TJLS supposedly increased its graduates' employability in the 2007-2010 years. If Beth Kransberger insists that this is really about a JD possibly diminishing in value solely from external economic forces, why was there no drop after the recession began in earnest?

The numbers cited in the complaint say that TJLS law graduates weren't terribly effected by the recession. Dean Kransberger suggests otherwise, that it might be "impractical" to get a JD because of the rough economy. Well, which is it? Either Kransberger is lying and it has little to do with the economy or - gasp - the numbers were misleading.

But this is a side issue about an administrator who apparently didn't think through her words. The real point is that this isn't an economic issue at all, but rather something that has gone on for years. The complaint itself goes back to the early 2000s and if the student enrolled in 2005, the recession was non-existent when she chose TJLS, which is the time point truly relevant to the fraud claim.

And as others have pointed out - including our favorite Emory speaker - the changes in the legal field are not temporary adjustments of scale to account for a revenue shortfall, but rather systemic changes that affect the number of laborers needed in the field. Law firms are continuing an ongoing change that drastically reduces the need for new law graduates. Kransberger and others use the recession as a salve, a sort-of "get out of jail free" card that can relieve them of their failure to adjust to the brave new world where menial tasks are sent to India, partner tracks are non-existent, and paid work for young attorneys generally evaporates.

We're at a very interesting point in the law school bubble with the commencement of this suit. Rumors are circulating about possible class actions in New York, California, and Michigan (please see the message on Nando's page if you attended law school in one of those states). I imagine someone, somewhere, is researching the Florida schools, the Massachusetts schools, and perhaps even the Illinois, Ohio, Virginia, or Texas schools. If this class action against TJLS is successful in any way whatsoever, about 180 lawsuits will be filed the very next day.

It's an interesting time period, and although I'm skeptical and not sure what will happen with this particular case, I'd be lying if I said I wasn't more optimistic for the future as a result. It's uncertain, and there are all sorts of hurdles and pitfalls and complications, but no one ever said undoing and correcting a lousy system was easy. The fact that there's now a professional, non-pro-se complaint written by a decently-sized Los Angeles firm filed against a law school is a huge step from where we were just a year ago.

Edit: I just found this article on Miller Barondess' website that makes Kransberger look like an even bigger fool than I thought she was. Choice quotes:

Kransberger said student debt involves complex class issues, since those without inherited family wealth will almost certainly have to take out loans. Thomas Jefferson’s students are 35 percent first-generation college students, 25 percent first¬generation U.S. citizens and 40 percent students of color, she said. The school is one of the least expensive in the state, with annual tuition at $40,100.
Yikes. If I was an attorney for TJLS, I'd put a muzzle on this woman and attach it with superglue. She basically admitted that the school targets poor minorities, who, one should note, are less likely to find legal work sufficient to pay off the debt than those who have preexisting connections. Sorry if I'm not being politically correct, but to be honest, the legal field isn't, either. Diverse law schools are only a good thing to academics concerned with what the working world sees as a frivolity. Surely the school knows this, since it's a training ground for the legal profession and all. Given that TJLS is alleged to be a bad investment engaging in deceptive practices, admitting that you were targeting an abnormally high number of minorities, poor people, and new arrivals (read: less-sophisticated parties) seems like a very ill-advised move. And the school being "one of the least expensive" is a tallest dwarf competition, or a purest hooker competition. You get the idea, even if Kransberger doesn't.
Kransberger said Thomas Jefferson doesn’t cater to the rankings and that she’s been appalled by reports of other schools’ misdeeds.
You mean like building a new campus while your honors graduates are unemployed or working as waiters?
“A law degree remains an amazingly versatile degree, and that continues to be what drives us.”
No, what "drives" you is abuse of federally-backed loans, you lying sack of garbage. Versatile, my ass. Does anyone believe that crap anymore? And note that she's countering a fraud allegation with a bald-faced lie. Stop and think about that for a second.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

This Week in Law Professor Justice

Three stories today about teachers in the legal profession getting into disciplinary matters.

First up, we have Quinnipiac assistant dean Mary Ellen Durso, who was "sentenced to three years of probation and six months of home confinement for her role in a scheme to defraud a mortgage lender and for filing false tax returns." The damage? $126,000. That's right, kids, if you're black and you deal a few thousand in drugs, you're going to prison. If you're an executive or administrator and you defraud people for ten times as much, you get home confinement. Brilliant.

Second, we have Widener professor Lawrence Connell, who I wrote about last month when he got in trouble for apparently doing what professors every do when he used the dean's name in some absurd hypos. Thankfully, it appears the faculty committee has some sense as they've recommended against firing him.

In an interesting twist, it seems Prof. Connell is actively investigating and plans to go after the students who denounced him:
"We're trying to figure out who those two students are right now. We've got it narrowed down to three," [Connell's attorney] said. "We can sue the students for defamation in state court immediately. We're not going to sit back and be a punching bag on this."
My desire for morbid entertainment has me hoping this will continue. Third-tier professor v. a few third-tier students who were probably annoyed they got B-'s on the curve. Has promise.

Third, we have George Washington adjunct lecturer Richard Lieberman, who was arrested by U.S. Customs authorities on six counts of child exploitation:
According to the charges, between Aug. 11 and Aug. 25, 2010, Mr. Lieberman used the Internet to sexually entice those he believed were two different girls under the age of 16 years. In fact, the charges said, he was engaging in online conversations with two undercover agents in Florida posing as 10 and 13-year-old girls.

Mr. Lieberman is accused of sending the “13-year-old girl” an image of a naked man, engaging in a sexually explicit conversation with the “10-year-old girl” and sending her website links to images of male and female genitalia.

GWU has already deleted his faculty profile (innocent until proven guilty, eh?), but if you go soon enough, you can see it on google cache.

Richard D. Lieberman is a principal in the Washington, D.C. firm of McCarthy, Sweeney & Harkaway, P.C., and has been a government contracts attorney since 1988, concentrating on counseling government contracts clients, claims, bid protests, criminal investigations, audits, contract compliance programs, Federal Supply (multiple award) Schedule contracts and debarment proceedings. He is a former deputy inspector general and assistant inspector general of the Department of Defense, where he was involved in the planning and execution of internal auditing, contract auditing, investigations and inspections. He also served as a professional staff member of the U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee and a budget analyst in the Office of the Department of Defense Comptroller.
Emphasis added. Again, innocent until proven guilty, but I'm not exactly sure what you can argue if the feds have transcripts of you sending 10-year olds to dirty websites.

Here's to hoping that if his guilt is proven, he gets something worse than three years of probation.

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Dumb Unethical New Attorneys is a Symptom, Not the Disease

As you've probably heard, there is an ongoing crisis not only with the wave of foreclosures, but how the foreclosures have been processed and handled in some areas, with rampant reports of fraud, incomplete documents, etc. You'll never guess what trait various investigative parties have noted about the attorneys who handled foreclosures in Florida:
Today, more than 260 attorneys work at four of Florida's largest foreclosure firms, and 48 percent of them have been practicing law for less than three years, according to Florida Bar records obtained by The Palm Beach Post.
...
With this fall's allegations of forged foreclosure documents, fraudulent notarizations and questionable affidavits submitted in tens of thousands of foreclosure cases, those nascent lawyers are now under a cloud of suspicion.

Some may face Florida Bar investigations that could end their careers, while homeowner advocates wonder whether the foreclosure crisis would have reached its state of disorder if it weren't for legions of novice lawyers doing the legwork.

Maybe I'm a bit naive, but something tells me that if you don't know using a forged affidavit or notarization is a bad thing on day one, you're probably not cut out to be an attorney. That said, it seems obvious that the Post was looking for a headline-grabbing scapegoat here and found one in youth rather than the system itself.

This becomes readily apparent if you read the whole article, which few did when newspapers were real and even fewer do online. Some select quotes:

  • Lack of experience could have led young lawyers to follow their employer's lead, unaware they may be committing an offense....
  • Florida Bar President Mayanne Downs said the Tallahassee-based group has no power to open its own inquiries....
  • [A former young attorney involved in foreclosures] said Stern's practice was driven by paralegals, who prepared most of the paperwork. "If there was shady stuff being done, it was being done without our knowledge," he said....
  • Even so, Downs said Bar leaders are generally concerned with the education of Florida's young attorneys. With 11 law schools in the state, she said there is a question about whether there are too many programs producing lower-caliber lawyers....
  • Downs suspects most cases the Bar investigates will result in blame being placed on a number of factors, including overwhelmed lenders, overworked firms and lack of oversight.

I wonder if Mayanne Downs has learned not to talk to reporters. In so many words, she told the entire world that her organization has no power to independently investigate dishonest firms, that the investigations they currently have will likely be blamed on factors other than unethical attorneys, and that the state's legal education may be in such disrepair that unqualified attorneys are being admitted to the bar her association is supposed to oversee.

That's the real problem here, isn't it? Sure, desperate, dumb young attorneys are a part of the mess, but that's not the headline here. The fact that there is a large mass of young attorneys desperate to do any kind of attorney work is a product of there being too many law graduates. Foreclosure mills and other legally-dubious enterprises can exist in such an atmosphere because the young attorneys - no matter how ethical they may be themselves - have little incentive to ask questions or look into what they're signing. One who takes the time to fulfill ethical obligations in any sort of idealistic sense is back to the unemployment line rather quickly. In a sense, it's the basic model of pre-unionized factories and 3rd-world sweatshops.

You could throw the book at the inexperienced attorneys who signed these fraudulent things, but in the end that's really only addressing a symptom. As long as there's a dirt cheap supply of competitive labor, you're playing right into the hands of shysters and exploiters because you've set up a system where an imbalance of power means the firm owners have a sort-of ethical monopoly. If the firm wants to discard legal ethics in the name of profit and take the risk, what prompts the young associate to say "no," if there's little other chance of a job and a 100k in student debt to pay off? If they say "no," eventually someone will say yes. If they report it to the authorities, there may be an investigation that results in the firm losing business, leaving the associate out of work.

Ultimately, bar associations are supposed to be the guardians against this type of situation by controlling the access of who gets to be an attorney in the first place. The fact that this situation happened isn't primarily the fault of young attorneys or even poor education, it's the fault of a system of bar associations (state and national) that has proven to be utterly ineffective at regulating the attorney profession, which has led to a drastic oversupply of attorneys and all associated problems. This is merely one of them; it is not the first apparent problem and it will not be the last.