Showing posts with label San Diego. Show all posts
Showing posts with label San Diego. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Response to San Diego Student Who Wrote In

Almost two months ago, I wrote a post critiquing the views of future University of San Diego student Marisa Mittelman as displayed in an article she wrote here.

Marisa apparently made a comment on my blog entry that was unfortunately eaten up by Blogger's aggressive spam filter, meaning I didn't see it until today. Here is the response in full (note: because blogger removed any paragraph breaks, I added some for clarity):

Firstly, I would like to congratulate you for being the first person ever to create a blog in which the sole aim is to spread negativity and pessimism! There aren't any other blogs like yours-- and most certainly not any with better layout, better writing, and better content.

That being said, I would like to clarify a few points:

1) You do not know me. Please do not presume that you know my financial situation, my geographical preferences, or what type of person I am.

2) I will proceed to provide you with some actual information, as opposed to pointless assumptions, about myself:

A) I intend to settle in San Diego. This has been my plan for some time. San Diego is an incredible place to live, and I cannot wait to move there. Since 25% of lawyers currently practicing in San Diego went to USD School of Law, more than any other school (Loyola comprises 1.8% and Pepperdine 1.1%), I stand by my statement that, for someone who intends to live in San Diego, USD is an amazing school (Source : californiabar.globl.org).

B) I am not taking out any more loans than I can handle. USD has provided me with a significant scholarship, and my family has been incredibly generous. Going to USD is in NO way, shape, or form a "catastrophic financial decision" for me, personally. I am not saying that is the case for every USD law student, but your promises of buyers remorse and my 20's being lost are unfounded.

C) I would have to argue that family law is a fantastic area for an eternal optimist. I am confident that IF that is the focus I choose (which, if you read the article, I note that it may not eventually be), that my bright outlook and sunny perspective will be great tools in helping couples facing difficult familial challenges, and children going through one of the hardest situations they may face.

So, while I deeply appreciate your condescending paternal advice, in this case I would have to question your failure to consider any alternatives to your decidedly depressing viewpoint. All the Best, Marisa L. Mittelman

I had a point-by-point response written out, but I think the situation calls for generality.

I don't write this blog for my health, or to show off my pessimism, or even to give advice. I write this blog because at one point in time I was in Marisa's place. I soon found that the system - not just law schools, but the whole legal ball of wax - is not what was presented to me (or what I perceived it to be), that hard working students are getting squeezed out of the market, that salaries are far lower than what's advertised, that being an attorney is not really prestigious, etc. I started this blog because I thought it could be part of a positive change that I feel needs to take place.

It's quite possible Marisa will have great success, both in law school and as attorney. Although she misread parts of the original entry, she seems to have the right attitude (ignoring sarcasm): she researched schools thoroughly, zealously defends her reasoning, sounds like she understands finances and the risks, etc. She's going in with her head up, and I won't be surprised if she does well at all.

But in the end, law school is an odds game in so many ways (some you don't even realize when you sign up), and the odds are far bleaker than any 0L ever calculates. Hard work is by no means a guarantee of anything, nor are good grades unless one is at a top school.

I would love for Marisa to review these posts in two to three years. Hopefully she'll look this up and beam with pride that she's got a sitting offer from the perfect San Diego firm/office, on the road to a satisfying legal career, carrying an investment in her education that reaps dividend after dividend.

Save for the San Diego part, I'd still like that for myself.

But the odds seem against it. And in any event, she'll certainly have classmates, those whose hard work she witnessed first-hand, wind up struggling, and maybe then she'll understand these blogs then, and that maybe all those unemployed students worked hard, after all, and that we don't exist just to be depressing.

Friday, June 3, 2011

An Interesting Answer from New San Diego Dean

The following is a question and answer from AmLaw Daily's recent interview with new U. of San Diego dean Stephen Ferruolo:

[Question]: Law schools have been under fire recently for reportedly misrepresenting post-graduation employment statistics. Did you consider that controversy before accepting the dean position?

[Answer]: I know, from the point of view of someone who's been running a law office for the past few years, what has been going on in the legal marketplace. The expectations of law students from the time they began three years ago to their graduation now have changed dramatically. Students have not been able to fund their lives the way they thought they would be able to when they started law school. But I still believe law is great training for a wide variety of opportunities out there. We just need to work hard to provide our students with the best training and show them the way to the best opportunities.
This may seem unremarkable to some, but notice how the answer doesn't exactly match what was asked. The question was only whether the indisputable controversy (like his lesser cross-town rival being sued) contributed in his decision regarding the job at all. You can admit that a controversy exists without conceding the most salient points of the "other side." And yet, our new San Diego dean didn't repeat the same ol' talking points, but rather admitted flatly that recent students are disgruntled with their return on investment, and that the end result does not match the incoming expectations.

Granted, Ferruolo is a long-time practitioner, so he likely missed the series of lectures about delivering academia propaganda while he was actually working, but consider how radical of a change this is from just a year or two ago, when administrators would defend their statistics and their graduates fortunes.

For all those of you considering going to San Diego law, consider this very carefully: the chief executive at your possible school just admitted publicly that the product did not meet the expectations of its consumers. Would you ever purchase, say, an oven if the CEO came out and said "yeah, the product isn't doing what everyone thought it would?" If the product being sold to you was the exact same thing with no substantive changes? Of course not!

But then one has to wonder: if someone straight from the front line of the legal marketplace says that students are not being able to "fund their lives," how is it that the median salary of San Diego graduates in the private sector is $97,000? And how is the "public service" sector salary $58,000? Will these numbers be similar next year after Dean Ferruolo lets everyone know that the legal marketplace is certainly NOT hiring half the "private sector" graduates at or above $97k??? Will San Diego tuition stay north of $41k to reflect the difficult reality for recent graduates, or will the plundering continue?

Only time will tell.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Law School Psychology 101 And A Texas A&M Law School?

When researchers study the psychology of consumers, they often find that individuals will continue researching information about a product they've already purchased after they've bought it in order to rationalize their behavior and cure any buyer's remorse.

We see this all the time among law students. Today's example would be Marisa Mittelman, who seems excited about going to the University of San Diego Law School in the fall:
When choosing between my final two schools (UC-Hastings and USD), however, I have to say that from every angle these things seemed nearly equal. I heard amazing things from students at both schools, saying they loved their professors, that the administration is always helpful and available, and that job prospects weren’t looking great anywhere. Is this last part discouraging? Of course. The fact is, though, that students who are working hard are still getting jobs. Clearly, the market is not what it once was. That applies to any law school, though, and I think that if you’re one hundred percent sure you want to be an attorney, you need to just sort of go for it. I plan to work my ass off and hope for the best—I don’t think there’s anything more that someone who is intent on practicing law can do.
Here's an idea: How about getting rid of this idea that's it's justifiable to make a bad decision so long as you're "intent on practicing law." Can you imagine this logic applying to any other product?

"But, honey, I was intent on being a Bentley owner! That's why I signed the papers!"

And Marisa is remarkably cavalier about the lack of job opportunities. "[S]tudents who are working hard are still getting jobs" is (a) complete crap that's disrespectful to recent graduates and unemployed 3Ls who are probably smarter than her; and (b) not dispositive of whether she'll have a job if she works hard. (On the bright side, you may not have a job, but you'll integrate words like "dispositive" into your everyday vocabulary.)

Again, this type of logic never shows up in intelligent investment situations. "Yes, I understand the entire sector is down in the toilet and has limited prospects, but this little stock is the best of this small, affordable bunch, so I'll buy it." Not quite. Getting a law school degree right now is like buying a house in 2007. It may work out for you. You might have a nice place to live. But it's a catastrophic financial decision even if you're "100 percent sure" you want to be a homeowner. There are much better options out there. A helpful administration and lovable professors can't pay bills or compensate for the loss of your mid-20s.

USD is an amazing school...Call me an eternal optimist, but I can’t wait to become a lawyer. And I can’t wait to begin my time at the University of San Diego School of Law.
Reality check: USD may be the best school in San Diego, but it is not a well-regarded law school outside that city, therefore it cannot be "an amazing school." This woman wants to be a family law attorney. There are two other law schools in San Diego who feed into areas like family law in addition to the transplants from places like Loyola and Pepperdine. And if she has any designs on moving back to New York, she'll be in for a rude awakening when Brooklyn Law School grads are beating her out for jobs.

And it's not like family law is generally a field for self-styled "eternal optimists," anyway, but she may be saved from that rude awakening by the rude awakening that a much-smaller-than-advertised segment of her graduating class will have full-time employment, no matter how hard they work.

As if it were bad enough that places like San Diego are still reeling in those blinded by an irrational desire to be a lawyer at all costs, Texas Governor Rick Perry threw out the idea of a Texas A&M law school:
Gov. Rick Perry floated the notion in an offhand comment today as he began a speech honoring women in the state Legislature. After being introduced by actress and conservative activist Janine Turner, the governor talked about trying to convince Turner’s 13-year-old daughter, an aspiring lawyer, to enroll at A&M, his alma mater.

“By the time you get there, they will have a law school,” Perry predicted.

With the rate they're being proposed by insane politicians, it wouldn't surprise me if he was serious in his intent to mar a great university with a bubble-fueled law school.