Showing posts with label versatility of a law degree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label versatility of a law degree. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

More Leach Entrepreneurship, Woman Getting Screwed As Much as Men, and Lawyers' Poor Predictive Abilities

1. Meet "Adam Smith," Capitalist Leach

It seems that the last few years have brought a rash of legal software gimmicks designed to pull money out of the bubble. There are multiple e-mail resume bombing platforms for recent graduates to throw money into an electro-abyss. Now the completely unintentionally-named Adam Smith, a "management consulting firm to the global legal industry," has launched JD Match, which will supposedly help large law firms better match with 2Ls during the "flawed" OCI/associate recruitment process.
Law students from any accredited U.S. law school can create a profile on JD Match for the inaugural fee of $99, which covers the 2011 2L recruiting season. Law firms joining JD Match pay an annual subscription fee based on their lawyer headcount, a common pricing structure for the profession. Membership for law schools is free.
Great, so now third-tier graduates can pay $99 to find out that big firms aren't hiring like they used to and that median-level law students at "prestigious" institutions will likely trump them, no matter how hard they work or how highly they are ranked or how good of future lawyers they actually are. Sounds like a winner.

2. Women Getting Screwed as Much as Men

From mlive.com:
Recently released Census figures confirm that for the first time, U.S. women surpassed men in gaining advanced college degrees as well as bachelor’s degrees.
...
When it comes to finishing college, roughly 20.1 million women have bachelor’s degrees, compared with nearly 18.7 million men. Women passed men in bachelor’s degrees in 1996.
Viva equality! Although the article phrases this as an unqualified positive, I'm not sure women being disproportionately burdened with student loan debt is any kind of a good result. There are already reports of couples refusing marriage and relationships over student loan debt. And not to sound non-PC, but I'm skeptical women have the same earning power as men if they're unable to find employment in their chosen educated field.

3. Lawyers' Poor Track Records

As Demosthenes pointed out yesterday, a recent study looking at the accuracy of predictions by pundits noted that "prognosticators with a law degree were more likely to be wrong."

This shouldn't be a surprise, but I imagine if you asked attorneys if they were good at predicting things, they would likely be more confident than others that their perception was correct. After all, a key part of lawyering involves predicting how a court would rule on something.

But the trick is that the real world is not a court. The real world is dynamic. Technology constantly changes the process of how things are done efficiently, while resource imbalances and shifts cause actors' values to subtly change over time. The real world has an infinity of variables that interplay and create a system that is chaotic and fueled by self-interested actors with very limited information.

A court attempts to provide certainty by removing the real world elements. Allegations of wrong are reduced to long-established causes of action. Evidence is reduced to that which the judge finds relevant and reliable. Despite the complexity of modern litigation, cases are presented simply, in a point-by-point manner with each side having an opportunity to bundle its case neatly. In contrast the to real world, the system is static and conservative. For example, American attitudes towards promiscuity have changed radically over the last century. But libel per se (assumed damages for falsely calling someone a whore) persisted regardless of dynamic social changes. There are numerous areas of law such as this, both substantive and procedural.

The point is that much of the law is about looking backwards, putting controlling weight on what authority figures did five years ago, what causes of action are already established, etc. The lawyer is not trained to predict how the world will change. The lawyer is trained to predict how the world will be if what happened in the past happens exactly as it did in the future. However, this is not realistic. History, hackneyed phrases aside, does not repeat itself. General rules of human behavior may develop, but any idea that the "rules" of the 1970s can be applied to the 2010s is so silly I shouldn't have to debunk it. And yet, attorneys regularly find themselves giving undue weight to overstated cases from the 70s and 80s in determining what will happen in their little sphere tomorrow. And if you find something dead on-point, then you have a very easy case and the world will not change.

There are merits in how the common law decides winners and losers, but attorneys and judges (and prospective law students) should be aware that it's a very artificial system that has no real-world application in how to "think" better than others'. If it did, lawyers may be more successful at starting businesses and investing than other people. But they're not; lawyers are regarded as notoriously bad businessmen, likely because they spent years of their lives thinking in very narrow, constructed boxes.

Yes, law school may teach you how to break something down piece-by-piece and argue variations on each piece against conflicting evidence. Often, sound policy determinations are emphasized. But the policy revelations are almost always retroactive, realized after some actors have started abusing the system. I fear as much as the law makes one "think" in a rational and isolated matter, for all the good that may bring, it seems like it might damage one's ability to see the big picture and think dynamically about how variables interplay with each other in a chaotic system. We really need people who can do that (e.g. invent things, propose new political ideas) and not more people who can pick the elements of a products liability claim and analyze them to death using reasoning from the pre-digital age.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

I Should Be Optimistic Because . . .

This is from Larry Ribstein, who has written previously about the slow collapse of biglaw and the future of the legal profession in general:
"I think the horizon for what you can do with a legal education hasn't shrunk, but has actually expanded," said Ribstein, the Mildred Van Voorhis Jones Chair in Law. "Change can be bad for some people, especially for those who have a stake in the current system, but it can also be good, and I think the future is going to be much more complex than envisioned by some critics."
When you say "those who have a stake in the current system," are you looking the mirror at all, Larry?

Regardless, I'm really intrigued by this idea that legal education is now opening more doors than it has in the past, what those doors are (I'd love to find one), and how the educational industry created those doors.

Unfortunately, none of those pesky details made it into the article. They must have been left on the editing room floor. Instead, the writer gives us a rather incoherent stream of reasoning including the following in an unconnected fashion:
  • Law schools should focus on meeting global demand.
  • Legal education hasn't changed much in the last century because of rigid accreditation standards.
  • Biglaw is dying.
  • Outsourcing is just a temporary stop-gap until the machines improve efficiency domestically and lawyer work becomes more exciting ("I think this is going to lead to an era of lawyers doing even more interesting things than they're doing now.")
  • Most of the professors working now will be dead or retired when these changes really change the profession (as opposed to them being affected by the scores of unemployed recent graduates).
But, yeah, there's room for optimism:
"The plus side for entering law students is that their future is much more wide open than that of their immediate predecessors," he said. "So that's a cause for optimism."
In the future, I hope we have law professors who actually back up their ridiculous statements with actual proof. Frankly, I think a law school graduate in 1960 had it much, much better than a law school graduate of 2010. That is, unless Ribstein can actually show us where these mystical doors that make the J.D. a versatile instead of a one-way ticket to attorney licensing.

The caption on the picture instructs the reader to be skeptical that the future of the legal profession is dire. If baseless statements like "you can do more with a legal education now!" are cause for optimism, I find my healthy skepticism is best used in the opposite direction, especially since people like Prof. Ribstein the marketers with the vested interest in keeping the system pumping.

In the meantime, I'll continue to consider statements like "the horizon for what you can do with a law degree hasn't shrunk, but has actually expanded" no better to the crap spewed by liberal arts advisers selling sociology degrees to future retail workers. Way to aim high, legal education.